ON AIR NOW

LISTEN NOW

Weather

clear-night
82°
Mostly Clear
H -° L 70°
  • clear-night
    82°
    Current Conditions
    Mostly Clear. H -° L 70°
  • clear-day
    Today
    Mostly Clear. H -° L 70°
  • clear-day
    94°
    Tomorrow
    Mostly Clear. H 94° L 71°
LISTEN
PAUSE
ERROR

Wsb news on-demand

00:00 | 00:00

LISTEN
PAUSE
ERROR

Wsb traffic on-demand

00:00 | 00:00

LISTEN
PAUSE
ERROR

Wsb weather on-demand

00:00 | 00:00

Local
Pretrial motions in the Grinstead murder case: A preview of a troubled trial
Close

Pretrial motions in the Grinstead murder case: A preview of a troubled trial

Pretrial motions in the Grinstead murder case: A preview of a troubled trial

Pretrial motions in the Grinstead murder case: A preview of a troubled trial

From a court watcher’s perspective it’s apparent to most that the upcoming trial of Ryan Duke, charged with the 2005 murder of South Georgia high school teacher Tara Grinstead is sure to be nothing short of a spectacle of epic proportions. We got a preview of things to come during - of all things - a bond hearing where Duke asked, for the first time in two years, to be released on bond. It wasn’t the denial of bond, nor the fact that Duke asked for bond that is particularly noteworthy. It’s what the bond hearing devolved into that raised eyebrows. Despite losing the motion, the defense unexpectedly was able to depose the lead GBI investigator on a wide range of topics in a dress rehearsal for what promises to be a most controversial trial. 

To start, let’s have a look at what a bond hearing is supposed to be. 

It’s uncommon for bond to be set in murder cases but it’s not unheard of. Courts are supposed to consider the following factors in making bond decisions and the burden of proof is on the defendant to show that he: 

  1. Poses no significant risk of fleeing from the jurisdiction of the court or failing to appear in court when required; 
  2. Poses no significant threat or danger to any person, to the community, or to any property in the community; 
  3. Poses no significant risk of committing any felony pending trial; and 
  4. Poses no significant risk of intimidating witnesses or otherwise obstructing the administration of justice. 

Probable cause is not an issue and of course neither is guilt or innocence. A bond hearing is not a trial. 

The Duke bond hearing started out as most bond hearings do. The defense called Duke’s brother to testify regarding each of the factors set out above. But then it started a downward spiral into the surreal when the prosecutor called the lead GBI case agent as a witness - presumably as a rebuttal to the defense. A state’s witness, such as an investigator, can occasionally testify - to a point - about “what happened” because that’s relevant - to a point - for the court to determine whether the person poses a danger to the community. But in this case, the testimony was literally all over the place and went into minute detail about many things that have never been heard before. The “bond hearing” was effectively transformed into a deposition - a legal luxury not normally available to a criminal defendant in Georgia. 

So just what did we learn from this “bond” hearing? We learned that DNA from the bodily fluid of a police officer was mixed with the victim’s blood on some bedding and that “touch DNA” from Grinstead and Duke (along with DNA from at least two other people) was on a latex glove found outside her residence. “Touch DNA” has its own share of problems in terms of reliability and we can safely expect the defense to explore those problems at trial. Some of that other unidentified DNA from the glove could have come from Bo Dukes - the person accused of helping cover up the murder - and who the defense claims is the actual killer. 

We learned there were many investigative steps that could have been taken to verify statements made by both Duke and Dukes. The defense will argue that these follow up steps point to a biased investigation. This could have a huge impact in a trial where the defense will claim that the defendants confession was a false confession. 

We learned the GBI, in a breach of protocol and constitutional law, interviewed / talked with Duke twice after he had a lawyer. These interviews were undocumented in the GBI case file. They were not recorded. The DA apparently was unaware at the time that this tactic was being employed by the GBI until the defense raised it with them. The agent didn’t even sign in at the jail. We can only speculate as to why not. 

On top of all this, an abundance of otherwise inadmissible evidence consisting of hearsay and innuendo managed to come out publicly at a bond hearing. Most of this wouldn’t have seen the light of day at a trial. As the prosecution correctly pointed out “hearsay” may be admissible at a bond hearing, but it still has to be reliable evidence - not a regurgitation of all the salacious rumors from 2005. And it must be relevant to the issue of bond. It may turn out that the DA made a great tactical mistake by calling their lead case agent to testify and turn this bond hearing into an evidentiary free-for-all with no apparent boundaries. At a minimum it was surely heartbreaking for friends and family of the victim to have to re-live all the pain of the last 13 years by having old wounds reopened in such painful detail. 

I’ve previously written about why the venue for this trial really needs to be changed. Now more than ever the jury pool is really tainted - as if it weren’t already.

Philip Holloway, WSB legal analyst, is a criminal lawyer who heads his own firm in Cobb County, Georgia. A former prosecutor and adjunct professor of criminal justice, he is former president of the Cobb County Bar Association's criminal law section. Follow him on Twitter: @PhilHollowayEsq The opinions expressed in this commentary are solely those of the author. 

Read More

News

  • In the Book of Genesis, Noah’s ark survived a flood in the Middle East. A replica of the biblical boat was not as lucky, and its owners are suing -- for damages caused by heavy rains in northern Kentucky. >> Read more trending news  The owners of Ark Encounter are suing their five insurance carriers for refusing to cover nearly $1 million in damages after flooding in 2017 and 2018 caused a landslide on its access road, the Louisville Courier Journal reported. In a 77-page lawsuit in U.S. District Court in Kentucky, Crosswater Canyon Inc. and the Ark Encounter sued the business’ insurance underwriters, WLWT reported. The ark’s owners are seeking compensatory and punitive damages, the Courier Journal reported. The ark, located in Williamstown, was not damaged.  According to the lawsuit, 'A significant landslide occurred along portions of the slope,” which caused “significant damage” to the road surface, making portions of the road “unsafe and unfit for use.” The road was fixed by engineers at a cost of $1 million, WLEX reported. But when the Ark Encounter asked its insurance underwriters to cover the cost of repairs, they were rebuffed, the television station reported. The Allied World Assurance Co. is named as a defendant, along with three other carriers, according to The Washington Post. Initially, the suit alleges, defendants cited faulty craftsmanship as the reason for the property damage and claimed they were not liable, WLEX reported. After an appeal, the defendants admitted that only a small amount was covered by the policy. The Ark Encounter, built at a cost of $120 million, opened in July 2016 with a zoo, zip lines and a restaurant in addition to the five-story replica of the ark, the Post reported. It was founded by Ken Ham and his ministry, Answers in Genesis, the newspaper reported. Ark Encounter spokeswoman Melany Ethridge distributed a statement that said “the lawsuit speaks for itself,” noting the park remained open. 'You got to get to the boat to be on the boat,' Ethridge told the Courier Journal.
  • Amanda Eller, who went missing more than two weeks ago in Maui has reportedly been found alive according to KHNL in Hawaii. >> Read more trending news The the 35-year-old woman was spotted by a helicopter in a wooded area sources told KHNL. Eller hadn’t been seen since May 8, when she disappeared after a hike in a Maui Forest Reserve, known for its steep and rugged terrain. Her vehicle was found with her cellphone and wallet inside in a parking lot at the reserve. WSOC-TV confirmed the news with Eller's aunt, Lynn Eller Ansley, by phone Friday night. Ansley is one of several relatives who live in North Carolina. Eller’s parents had offered a $10,000 reward for information leading to her safe return. The Associated Press contributed to this report.
  • Officers found snakes, alligators and talking birds inside a Marion, Arkansas, home. >> Read more trending news William Hale, 47, is charged with 60 counts of aggravated animal cruelty after investigators found the exotic animals inside his home. One neighbor took pictures of the snakes he saw investigators taking out of the home. WHBQ-TV received a tip yesterday from a source who said the conditions were so unbearable that even the hazmat team could not handle it. He said the birds they found in that home were having full conversations with the investigators. “Tropical birds, I seen a parrot. Actually he had, like, seven of those, different type of birds, and I seen, like, 30 snakes,” Terrence Blackburn, a neighbor, said. “The bulldog was one of the first animals to come out, and there were five of those. I seen a poodle,” Blackburn said. Yellow caution tape surrounds the home. “I seen the alligator, which they had, it was a small baby alligator and I heard it was like nine of them,” Blackburn said. Investigators with the Marion Police Department told WHBQ-TV Animal Control officers responded to the home after complaints about barking dogs. “And you had no idea this was going on, no idea,” Blackburn said. Hale was not home at the time. He did not show up after officers spoke with him over the phone requesting his return. According to officers, that is when they conducted a search warrant and found several exotic animals that were not being properly cared for. “I would let him know that was kind of wrong. You know, we have kids over here, and them are dangerous animals,” Blackburn said. A source gave confirmation that there were several alligators inside that home yesterday.
  • Officials at Muskogee War Memorial Park said the Oklahoma Department of Emergency Management and the National Guard took over the site Friday due to severe flooding. >> Read more trending news The park is home to the USS Batfish, a World War II-era submarine that now serves as a museum. Park staff and volunteers are being used to support emergency officials in managing the scene. Officials said at least one line on the Batfish has broken and they are working to keep it from floating away. Crews are filling the ballast tanks on board the USS Batfish to keep it inside the park's bowl. The National Guard also tied a new line to the boat to add leverage. Those interested in helping support the memorial and any potential repair costs can visit this link for more information.
  • A Walt Disney World employee from Clermont, Florida, was arrested on charges of trying to have sex with an 8-year-old girl. >> Read more trending news Investigators said Frederick Pohl Jr., 40, thought he was chatting with the father of the victim, but he was chatting with an undercover agent. The two arranged to meet at an Orlando hotel Tuesday and that's where Pohl was arrested. Investigators said Pohl was in possession of condoms and a child-sized pink dress. Authorities said Pohl was charged with transferring obscene materials to a minor and attempting to entice a minor. If convicted, Pohl faces a maximum penalty of life in federal prison. Disney said Pohl was placed on unpaid leave of absence.
  • A Gwinnett County, Georgia, police K-9 died Thursday after pursuing a man in 90-degree heat, authorities said. >> Read more trending news Eli, a 9-year-old police dog, had been tracking a man in Grayson, Georgia, for about 30 minutes when he began to show signs of distress believed to be related to the heat, Gwinnett police said in a news release. Eli and his handler, Officer Matthew Bonanno, were assisting Snellville police in a pursuit after a man fled from officers near North Crestview Drive and Grayson Parkway, police said. After showing signs of distress, the dog was removed from the chase, according to police. As Eli and officers walked back to their patrol vehicles, the dog fell to the ground and began to act abnormally, police said.  In an effort to cool him down, officers covered Eli’s body with water. He was taken to a nearby veterinarian for treatment, where he stopped breathing. Vets performed CPR for about 30 minutes before he was pronounced dead just before 5 p.m. “We mourn the loss of this courageous K-9 and will provide more details at a later time,” Gwinnett police said, calling the situation tragic. “Please keep Officer Bonnano and his family in your thoughts.” Eli had been with the department for eight years. His body was taken to the University of Georgia, where a necropsy is being conducted to determine a cause of death, Gwinnett police said Friday. Snellville police said the pursuit began when a woman called 911 to report that her ex-boyfriend was following her in his car. At one point, the man reportedly struck the woman from behind in traffic, authorities said. The altercation began on U.S. 78 in DeKalb County before continuing into Gwinnett, police said. Snellville officers pursued the man into a neighborhood, where he abandoned his vehicle and ran away, prompting officers to call for a K-9. The man, whose name was not released, has still not been found.