On Air Now

Listen Now

Weather

cloudy-day
73°
Chance of T-storms
H 85° L 70°
  • cloudy-day
    73°
    Current Conditions
    Chance of T-storms. H 85° L 70°
  • partly-cloudy-tstorms-day
    85°
    Today
    Chance of T-storms. H 85° L 70°
  • partly-cloudy-tstorms-day
    88°
    Tomorrow
    Chance of T-storms. H 88° L 72°
Listen
Pause
Error

News on-demand

00:00 | 00:00

Listen
Pause
Error

Traffic on-demand

00:00 | 00:00

Listen
Pause
Error

Weather on-demand

00:00 | 00:00

College
Georgia-LSU: Which team has the edge from the recruiting trail?
Close

Georgia-LSU: Which team has the edge from the recruiting trail?

Georgia-LSU: Which team has the edge from the recruiting trail?

Georgia-LSU: Which team has the edge from the recruiting trail?

Plays. Players. How does the Georgia-LSU game break down in those areas for the SEC championship on Saturday?

The edge in plays would tilt in LSU's favor. The Tigers have the leading Heisman Trophy contender in Joe Burrow. The redshirt senior transfer has put up perhaps the greatest statistical season for any quarterback in SEC history. Especially just the pure passing numbers.

His top receiver, Ja'Marr Chase, is up for the Fred Biletnikoff Award after ripping off 70 catches for 1,457 yards and 17 touchdowns in 2019.

Junior RB Clyde Edwards-Helaire actually has produced better stats in the ground game than Georgia's nationally-respected tailback D'Andre Swift.

LSU seems to have more players up for more hardware. Its season highlight reel at least offensively may be in need of some Ken Burns help on the mini-series side. Georgia's resume will counter with a strong dose of defensive prowess.

Defensive rankings (Georgia)

  • Rushing defense (1st in the SEC; 2nd nationally)
  • Scoring defense (1st in the SEC; 2nd nationally)
  • Total defense (1st in the SEC; 5th nationally)
  • Pass efficiency defense (1st in the SEC; 3rd nationally)

The continued discussion here, at least for the purposes of this narrative, leads to the recruiting trail. Which team has recruited better over the last few cycles?

The answer there would be Georgia.

Check out the overall national ratings from the 247Sports Team Composite rating for each program over the last four cycles:

  • 2016 rankings: LSU (2nd); UGA (6th)
  • 2017 rankings: LSU (7th); UGA (3rd)
  • 2018 rankings: LSU (15th); UGA (1st)
  • 2019 rankings: LSU (5th); UGA (2nd)
  • Average ranking: LSU (7th); UGA (3rd)

Which team has signed more 5-star prospects over that period? The team with the edge there would again be Georgia.

  • 5-stars signed (2016-2019): LSU 8; UGA 18

DawgNation has pointed to the well-documented "blue-chip" ratio with its weekly matchup coverage for this season. That ratio tracks the number of 4 and 5-star prospects that have been signed by each school over the last four cycles.

The players with those ratings are seen as the most desired and highest-rated recruiting prospects in each year. There are approximately 380 players every cycle that earn at least a 4-star rating. It means that those are by and large the players targeted heavily by all 130 of the programs in the NCAA's Football Bowls Subdivision.

The Bulldogs have gone into each game week having signed a decided edge in talent over its biggest SEC rivals. The blue-chip ratio was +69 for Georgia Tech last week, but also +30 against Texas A&M, +23 against Auburn, +29 against Auburn and +26 against Notre Dame, among others.

The Bulldogs will again have the edge on Saturday in Mercedes-Benz Stadium, but the gap isn't as wide.

  • Blue-chip signees (2016-2019): UGA 75; LSU 59.

Georgia-LSU: The signees no longer with each program

The figures presented so far offer a concise way to look at which sideline should have the edge in talent on Saturday, but there's a fallacy to that.

There are better ways to try to find a truer reading in terms of which team was made up of the more talented recruits. That's found by taking a deep look at the 2016 classes for each team.

Georgia signed three of its 5-stars from that previously-stated tally in 2016. Those three are already in the NFL. LSU also no longer has one of its three players in the program that carried a 5-star rating in 2016.

Those 2016 classes will not be well-represented on Saturday. Georgia has only retained five of its 13 blue-chip signees through the 2019 season and two of those have not been a major factor this season.

LSU is missing eight of its 2016 signees, too. It speaks to the attrition rate, the transfer portal business and it also detracts from that 75-59 edge for Georgia in blue-chip signees over the last four cycles.

The Tigers no longer have 12 of its 59 blue-chip signees since then in their program.

The "actual" blue-chip ratio now rings truer with a 59-47 edge for the Bulldogs. The summation of the 5-star signees that are still with each program will also reflect those roster subtractions.

Georgia's 5-star count drops to 13. LSU will also still have seven of its 5-star signees since 2016 available to take on the Bulldogs.

Georgia-LSU: The unexpected data from the recruiting trail

While presenting the many different ways to look at each team's recruiting of late, we must be clear here to point out a few things.

Nobody gets any points on the scoreboard for signing more 5-stars or 4-stars.

Burrow was also not a part of any of those calculations. He was a 4-star redshirt transfer. Not a signee. The future All-American was "just" the No. 280 overall prospect in the 2015 class.

The same goes for Edwards-Helaire, too. He was just a 3-star all-purpose back in the 2017 class. That young man certainly has out-played his recruiting evaluation. Georgia coach Kirby Smart said this week he back was the pristine image of what you look for in any program.

That thinking will also apply to a pair of Bulldogs that definitely rate among the top players on that stingy Georgia defense. Senior safety J.R. Reed was a 3-star transfer from Tulsa and yet he's up for the Bronko Nagurski and Jim Thorpe Awards.

Eric Stokes, who has been Georgia's top cover corner over the balance of this season, was also just a raw 3-star recruit. There are other examples of player development and the notion of 3-star recruits still being mighty fine players across both rosters.

The expected starting lineups for each team will also provide a final full example of how the work on the recruiting trail has shaped both rosters for Saturday's SEC championship game.

Blue-chip ratio: Georgia offense versus the LSU defense

Take a look at the grids below. Georgia's offense would seem like it had the talent potential to be the more effective unit compared to its defense. That's not exactly the case.

Georgia starting offense (probable) Star rating Pos. rank Blue-chip Blue-chip reserves
QB Jake Fromm (Jr.) 4 No. 4 PRO Yes No
RB D'Andre Swift (Jr.) 5 No. 4 RB Yes Yes
WR Tyler Simmons (Sr.) 3 No. 65 WR No Yes
LT Andrew Thomas (Jr.) 4 No. 9 OT Yes Yes
LG Solomon Kindley (RS-Jr.) 3 No. 89 OT No Yes
C Trey Hill (So.) 4 No. 3 OG Yes Yes
RG Ben Cleveland (RS-Jr.) 4 No. 10 OT Yes Yes
RT Isaiah Wilson (RS-So.) 5 No. 5 OT Yes Yes
TE Charlie Woerner (Sr.) 4 No. 25 WR Yes Yes
WR Kearis Jackson (R-Fr.) 4 No. 23 WR Yes Yes
WR Dominick Blaylock (Fr.) 4 No. 5 WR Yes Yes
Total blue-chip starters on offense 9
Top 10 recruits on offense (position ranks) 7
LSU starting defense (probable) Star rating Pos. rank Blue-chip Blue-chip reserves
DE Glen Logan (RS-Jr.) 4 No. 18 DT Yes Yes
NT Tyler Shelvin (RS-So.) 4 No. 4 DT Yes Yes
DE Rashard Lawrence (Sr.) 5 No. 5 DT Yes Yes
OLB Damone Clark (So.) 4 No. 20 ILB Yes Yes
MLB Patrick Queen (Jr.) 4 No. 17 ATH Yes Yes
MLB Jacob Phillips (Jr.) 4 No. 1 ILB Yes Yes
OLB K'Lavion Chaisson (Jr.) 4 No. 4 WDE Yes Yes
CB Derek Stingley (Fr.) 5 No. 1 CB Yes Yes
FS Jacoby Stevens (Jr.) 5 No. 1 S Yes Yes
SS Grant Delpit (Jr.) 4 No. 9 S Yes Yes
CB Kristian Fulton (Sr.) 5 No. 3 CB Yes Yes
Total blue-chip starters on defense 11
Top 10 recruits on defense (position ranks) 7

That LSU defense was also filled up by big recruiting wins. Every member of that unit was a blue-chip prospect coming out of high school, including seven starters which rated among the nation's top 10 recruits at their positions.

Blue-chip ratio: Georgia defense versus the LSU offense

The same point applies to LSU and its offense. That prolific unit didn't have as many upper-echelon athletes as the Tigers on the defensive side of the ball. At least when they arrived in Baton Rogue.

The same can be said for Georgia's nationally-elite defense.

The point can be made that the meeting between the LSU offense and the Georgia defense has the potential to be as good as any offensive vs. defensive matchup that fans have been treated to so far season.

LSU starting offense (probable) Star rating Pos. rank Blue-chip Blue-chip reserves
QB Joe Burrow (Sr.) 4 No. 8 DUAL Yes Yes
RB Clyde Edwards-Helaire (Jr.) 3 No. 5 APB No Yes
WR Justin Jefferson (Jr.) 3 No. 308 WR No Yes
LT Saahdiq Charles (Jr.) 4 No. 18 OG Yes Yes
LG Adrian McGee (RS-Sr.) 3 No. 45 OT No Yes
C Lloyd Cushenberry (RS-Jr.) 3 No. 82 OG No Yes
RG Damien Lewis (Sr.) 3 No. 2 OG (JUCO) No Yes
RT Austin Deculus (Jr.) 4 No. 10 OT Yes Yes
TE Thaddeus Moss (RS-Jr.) 3 No. 17 TE No Yes
WR JaMarr Chase (So.) 4 No. 15 WR Yes Yes
WR Terrace Marshall (So.) 5 No. 3 WR Yes Yes
Total blue-chip starters on offense 5
Top 10 recruits on offense (position ranks) 3
Georgia starting defense (probable) Star rating Pos. rank Blue-chip Blue-chip reserves
DT Tyler Clark (Sr.) 4 No. 27 DT Yes Yes
NT Michael Barnett (R-Sr.) 4 No. 14 SDE Yes Yes
DE Malik Herring (Jr.) 4 No. 4 SDE Yes Yes
OLB Azeez Ojulari (R-Fr.) 4 No. 10 DE Yes Yes
MLB Tae Crowder (R-Sr.) 3 No. 221 WR No Yes
WLB Monty Rice (Jr.) 4 No. 18 ILB Yes Yes
CB Eric Stokes (R-So.) 3 No. 63 CB No Yes
S Richard LeCounte II (Jr.) 5 No. 2 S Yes Yes
S J.R. Reed (RS-Sr.) 3 No. 157 CB No Yes
CB D.J. Daniel (Jr.) 4 No. 2 CB (JUCO) Yes Yes
STAR Mark Webb (Jr.) 4 No. 21 WR Yes Yes
Total blue-chip starters on defense 8
Top 10 recruits on defense (position ranks) 3

Check the values from the above table.

It is highly ironic that this specific on-field matchup will still only feature six combined players which rated as a top 10 national recruit at their position coming out of high school.

The fact that LSU receiver Justin Jefferson (81, catches, 1,02 yards, 13 TDs) was not a true blue-chip recruit speaks to the inexact sciences of recruiting rankings. While the scouting accuracy for recruiting has never been better given the prevalence of college schemes and evaluation camps now common to high school football, nothing is absolute.

Of the 18 prospects with the 5-star ratings that Georgia has signed of late, there are only three or four of those that present a good chance to start on Saturday. Sometimes college football (elite coaching, player development, player work ethic traits for the good or bad) happen and those rankings serve as motivational chips for the other players on these rosters, too.

Georgia-LSU: The stories so far on Dawgnation

The post Georgia-LSU: Which team has the edge from the recruiting trail? appeared first on DawgNation.

Read More

News

  • A driver died Wednesday morning after a fiery crash on a major interstate in Gwinnett County.  The wreck, which involved a truck and an SUV, happened about 1:30 a.m. on I-85 at Jimmy Carter Boulevard, according to Gwinnett police spokeswoman Cpl. Michele Pihera.  The truck caught fire after the crash, and the driver had to be freed from the vehicle, she said.  A Gwinnett police officer was injured during the rescue effort, according to Pihera. The officer was checked out at a hospital and released.  One driver died on the way to a hospital, Pihera said. It is not clear which vehicle that person was driving.  No details were released about the second driver’s condition. — Return HERE for updates from The Atlanta Journal Constitution.
  • About a dozen American flags lined up along Highland Avenue in Needham, Massachusetts, were burned Sunday night, according to police. A dozen more flags set on the lawn near the Exchange Club were found destroyed, as well. According to Boston's WFXT, the flags have been replaced, but the ashes are still scattered along the grass. Longtime Needham resident Kate Robey takes it upon herself to display the flags on Highland Avenue during patriotic holidays. “I think everyone appreciates it. I get honks and the waves and the thank-yous,” Robey said. But this Fourth of July, the flags were vandalized. “Dedicated people put those out and to just burn them, nonchalantly, it’s hurtful,” said Robey. Robey has been working with the Needham VFW for years and has displayed these flags in the same parts of town for almost a decade now. She’s left confused and wondering why someone would vandalize her tribute to the men and women serving the country. “As I do the flags, I think of the veterans, fallen brave and the military out there fighting for our freedom now,” Robey said. Robey said about a dozen were burned by Memorial Park and a dozen more burned outside the Needham Exchange Club, where 500 flags were displayed in lieu of a scaled-back Fourth of July celebration. “I don’t mind what you do at your home with your flags, but these flags are my flags, and it’s vandalism,” Robey said. Police said they are investigating the matter.
  • An off-duty volunteer firefighter is being hailed as a hero after he rescued a baby while swimming at a Maryland park. According to the Oakland Volunteer Fire Department, one of its firefighters, Andrew Bell, heard a woman shouting as he swam at Swallow Falls State Park while off-duty on Sunday.  'A raft that a baby was floating on had flipped over, and the baby went into the water,' the department said in a Facebook post Sunday night.  Bell quickly found the baby, who was unconscious, the Cumberland Times-News reported.  'I put it on its back for a little bit, and it started spitting up water,' Bell told the newspaper.  Bell then called an ambulance and continued to help the family until rescue crews arrived, the Fire Department said. 'It's our understanding that baby is going to be OK,' the department added. 'Great work, FF Bell!' Bell told the Times-News that even though he wasn't on duty at the time of the incident, it was still his 'duty to go help that person.' Read more here or here.
  • A PGA golf pro, his son and two stepchildren were among the eight people who died in an Idaho plane crash Sunday, multiple news outlets are reporting. According to KPTV, Oregon residents Sean Fredrickson, 48; son Hayden Fredrickson, 16; and stepchildren Sofia Olsen, 15, and Quinn Olsen, 11, were killed Sunday afternoon when two planes collided over Idaho's Lake Coeur d'Alene and crashed into the water. All eight people on the two planes died in the crash, the Kootenai County Sheriff's Office said. Authorities said Fredrickson and the children were on board a Brooks Seaplane piloted by 58-year-old Neil Lunt of Liberty Lake, Washington, at the time of the crash, the Spokesman-Review reported. Officials have not yet identified a sixth person who also was on the plane.  The two people on board the other plane, a Cessna TU206G, have been identified, but officials have not publicly released their names, according to the Spokesman-Review. As of Tuesday, crews were still working to recover two of the victims' bodies, the newspaper reported.  Fredrickson, the Pacific Northwest PGA Section's president, was the lead golf pro at Oregon's Oswego Lake Country Club, according to KPTV. “A rising star in the PGA, Sean led the Section through an unprecedented time, first taking the reins a year early as president and then leading us wisely through this pandemic,” the Pacific Northwest PGA Section said in a statement. “We are all better because of Sean’s leadership over the past 12 years.” Fredrickson's wife, April Fredrickson, told KPTV that her family 'died while they were on an adventure.' 'I think that, at the end of the day, they died doing what they loved, which was ... being together,' she told the news outlet. Read more here or here.
  • Atlanta police released a new video and surveillance photos from its investigation into the shooting death of an 8-year-old girl. According to WSB-TV, Secoriea Turner was shot while riding in a car with her mother and her mother’s friend Saturday night. The shooting happened not far from the Wendy’s on University Avenue where Rayshard Brooks was shot and killed last month. The video shows a Black man in a white shirt carrying what police identified as an AR-15. Lt. Pete Malecki said the man is just one of several persons of interest in the case. “We believe there is going to be a minimum of three additional suspects. That number could change,” he said. “Although we have a lot of work to identify the remaining individuals responsible, this is the first step in that process.” Investigators said Secoriea Turner was riding in a Jeep Cherokee Saturday night when the driver tried to get around a “makeshift roadblock that was manned by numerous armed individuals.” Malecki said they believe the shots were fired intentionally into the car. At a news conference Sunday, Secoriea Turner’s mother said that her daughter died in her arms. “She was only 8 years old,” Charmaine Turner said. “She would have been on Tik Tok dancing on her phone, just got done eating. We understand the frustration of Rayshard Brooks. We didn’t have anything to do with that. We’re innocent. My baby didn’t mean no harm.” Secoriya Williamson, Secoriea Turner’s father, also spoke out. “They say Black lives matter,” Williamson said. “You killed your own this time. You killed a child. She didn’t do nothing to nobody.” Police are offering a $20,000 reward for information leading to Secoriea Turner’s killers. Information can be submitted anonymously to the Crime Stoppers Atlanta tip line at 404-577-TIPS (8477) or online at www.StopCrimeATL.com. Hours following the police news conference, the community came together for a prayer vigil.
  • A 17-month-old girl was killed in a pit bull attack last weekend during a Fourth of July party in Illinois, authorities said. According to The Associated Press and WMAQ-TV, the incident occurred early Sunday in the bedroom of a family friend's Joliet home. The toddler, whose parents were attending a holiday gathering at the residence, was in a playpen when two dogs somehow got free from the basement, Joliet police said. After hearing a noise, the homeowner went into the bedroom to find one of the two dogs – both pit bull mixes – biting the child, the AP reported. Authorities responded to the home shortly before 1:30 a.m. and found the girl unresponsive with multiple bite wounds, the Herald-News reported. Crews rushed her to a nearby hospital, where she later died. The Will County Coroner's Office identified the victim as Marley Wilander, according to the newspaper. The dog is now in the custody of Animal Control, police said.  – The Associated Press contributed to this report.