On Air Now

Listen Now

Weather

cloudy-day
41°
Drizzle
H -° L 37°
  • cloudy-day
    41°
    Current Conditions
    Drizzle. H -° L 37°
  • heavy-rain-day
    Today
    Drizzle. H -° L 37°
  • clear-day
    54°
    Tomorrow
    Mostly Clear. H 54° L 37°
Listen
Pause
Error

News on-demand

00:00 | 00:00

Listen
Pause
Error

Traffic on-demand

00:00 | 00:00

Listen
Pause
Error

Weather on-demand

00:00 | 00:00

College
Georgia-LSU: Which team has the edge from the recruiting trail?
Close

Georgia-LSU: Which team has the edge from the recruiting trail?

Georgia-LSU: Which team has the edge from the recruiting trail?

Georgia-LSU: Which team has the edge from the recruiting trail?

Plays. Players. How does the Georgia-LSU game break down in those areas for the SEC championship on Saturday?

The edge in plays would tilt in LSU's favor. The Tigers have the leading Heisman Trophy contender in Joe Burrow. The redshirt senior transfer has put up perhaps the greatest statistical season for any quarterback in SEC history. Especially just the pure passing numbers.

His top receiver, Ja'Marr Chase, is up for the Fred Biletnikoff Award after ripping off 70 catches for 1,457 yards and 17 touchdowns in 2019.

Junior RB Clyde Edwards-Helaire actually has produced better stats in the ground game than Georgia's nationally-respected tailback D'Andre Swift.

LSU seems to have more players up for more hardware. Its season highlight reel at least offensively may be in need of some Ken Burns help on the mini-series side. Georgia's resume will counter with a strong dose of defensive prowess.

Defensive rankings (Georgia)

  • Rushing defense (1st in the SEC; 2nd nationally)
  • Scoring defense (1st in the SEC; 2nd nationally)
  • Total defense (1st in the SEC; 5th nationally)
  • Pass efficiency defense (1st in the SEC; 3rd nationally)

The continued discussion here, at least for the purposes of this narrative, leads to the recruiting trail. Which team has recruited better over the last few cycles?

The answer there would be Georgia.

Check out the overall national ratings from the 247Sports Team Composite rating for each program over the last four cycles:

  • 2016 rankings: LSU (2nd); UGA (6th)
  • 2017 rankings: LSU (7th); UGA (3rd)
  • 2018 rankings: LSU (15th); UGA (1st)
  • 2019 rankings: LSU (5th); UGA (2nd)
  • Average ranking: LSU (7th); UGA (3rd)

Which team has signed more 5-star prospects over that period? The team with the edge there would again be Georgia.

  • 5-stars signed (2016-2019): LSU 8; UGA 18

DawgNation has pointed to the well-documented "blue-chip" ratio with its weekly matchup coverage for this season. That ratio tracks the number of 4 and 5-star prospects that have been signed by each school over the last four cycles.

The players with those ratings are seen as the most desired and highest-rated recruiting prospects in each year. There are approximately 380 players every cycle that earn at least a 4-star rating. It means that those are by and large the players targeted heavily by all 130 of the programs in the NCAA's Football Bowls Subdivision.

The Bulldogs have gone into each game week having signed a decided edge in talent over its biggest SEC rivals. The blue-chip ratio was +69 for Georgia Tech last week, but also +30 against Texas A&M, +23 against Auburn, +29 against Auburn and +26 against Notre Dame, among others.

The Bulldogs will again have the edge on Saturday in Mercedes-Benz Stadium, but the gap isn't as wide.

  • Blue-chip signees (2016-2019): UGA 75; LSU 59.

Georgia-LSU: The signees no longer with each program

The figures presented so far offer a concise way to look at which sideline should have the edge in talent on Saturday, but there's a fallacy to that.

There are better ways to try to find a truer reading in terms of which team was made up of the more talented recruits. That's found by taking a deep look at the 2016 classes for each team.

Georgia signed three of its 5-stars from that previously-stated tally in 2016. Those three are already in the NFL. LSU also no longer has one of its three players in the program that carried a 5-star rating in 2016.

Those 2016 classes will not be well-represented on Saturday. Georgia has only retained five of its 13 blue-chip signees through the 2019 season and two of those have not been a major factor this season.

LSU is missing eight of its 2016 signees, too. It speaks to the attrition rate, the transfer portal business and it also detracts from that 75-59 edge for Georgia in blue-chip signees over the last four cycles.

The Tigers no longer have 12 of its 59 blue-chip signees since then in their program.

The "actual" blue-chip ratio now rings truer with a 59-47 edge for the Bulldogs. The summation of the 5-star signees that are still with each program will also reflect those roster subtractions.

Georgia's 5-star count drops to 13. LSU will also still have seven of its 5-star signees since 2016 available to take on the Bulldogs.

Georgia-LSU: The unexpected data from the recruiting trail

While presenting the many different ways to look at each team's recruiting of late, we must be clear here to point out a few things.

Nobody gets any points on the scoreboard for signing more 5-stars or 4-stars.

Burrow was also not a part of any of those calculations. He was a 4-star redshirt transfer. Not a signee. The future All-American was "just" the No. 280 overall prospect in the 2015 class.

The same goes for Edwards-Helaire, too. He was just a 3-star all-purpose back in the 2017 class. That young man certainly has out-played his recruiting evaluation. Georgia coach Kirby Smart said this week he back was the pristine image of what you look for in any program.

That thinking will also apply to a pair of Bulldogs that definitely rate among the top players on that stingy Georgia defense. Senior safety J.R. Reed was a 3-star transfer from Tulsa and yet he's up for the Bronko Nagurski and Jim Thorpe Awards.

Eric Stokes, who has been Georgia's top cover corner over the balance of this season, was also just a raw 3-star recruit. There are other examples of player development and the notion of 3-star recruits still being mighty fine players across both rosters.

The expected starting lineups for each team will also provide a final full example of how the work on the recruiting trail has shaped both rosters for Saturday's SEC championship game.

Blue-chip ratio: Georgia offense versus the LSU defense

Take a look at the grids below. Georgia's offense would seem like it had the talent potential to be the more effective unit compared to its defense. That's not exactly the case.

Georgia starting offense (probable) Star rating Pos. rank Blue-chip Blue-chip reserves
QB Jake Fromm (Jr.) 4 No. 4 PRO Yes No
RB D'Andre Swift (Jr.) 5 No. 4 RB Yes Yes
WR Tyler Simmons (Sr.) 3 No. 65 WR No Yes
LT Andrew Thomas (Jr.) 4 No. 9 OT Yes Yes
LG Solomon Kindley (RS-Jr.) 3 No. 89 OT No Yes
C Trey Hill (So.) 4 No. 3 OG Yes Yes
RG Ben Cleveland (RS-Jr.) 4 No. 10 OT Yes Yes
RT Isaiah Wilson (RS-So.) 5 No. 5 OT Yes Yes
TE Charlie Woerner (Sr.) 4 No. 25 WR Yes Yes
WR Kearis Jackson (R-Fr.) 4 No. 23 WR Yes Yes
WR Dominick Blaylock (Fr.) 4 No. 5 WR Yes Yes
Total blue-chip starters on offense 9
Top 10 recruits on offense (position ranks) 7
LSU starting defense (probable) Star rating Pos. rank Blue-chip Blue-chip reserves
DE Glen Logan (RS-Jr.) 4 No. 18 DT Yes Yes
NT Tyler Shelvin (RS-So.) 4 No. 4 DT Yes Yes
DE Rashard Lawrence (Sr.) 5 No. 5 DT Yes Yes
OLB Damone Clark (So.) 4 No. 20 ILB Yes Yes
MLB Patrick Queen (Jr.) 4 No. 17 ATH Yes Yes
MLB Jacob Phillips (Jr.) 4 No. 1 ILB Yes Yes
OLB K'Lavion Chaisson (Jr.) 4 No. 4 WDE Yes Yes
CB Derek Stingley (Fr.) 5 No. 1 CB Yes Yes
FS Jacoby Stevens (Jr.) 5 No. 1 S Yes Yes
SS Grant Delpit (Jr.) 4 No. 9 S Yes Yes
CB Kristian Fulton (Sr.) 5 No. 3 CB Yes Yes
Total blue-chip starters on defense 11
Top 10 recruits on defense (position ranks) 7

That LSU defense was also filled up by big recruiting wins. Every member of that unit was a blue-chip prospect coming out of high school, including seven starters which rated among the nation's top 10 recruits at their positions.

Blue-chip ratio: Georgia defense versus the LSU offense

The same point applies to LSU and its offense. That prolific unit didn't have as many upper-echelon athletes as the Tigers on the defensive side of the ball. At least when they arrived in Baton Rogue.

The same can be said for Georgia's nationally-elite defense.

The point can be made that the meeting between the LSU offense and the Georgia defense has the potential to be as good as any offensive vs. defensive matchup that fans have been treated to so far season.

LSU starting offense (probable) Star rating Pos. rank Blue-chip Blue-chip reserves
QB Joe Burrow (Sr.) 4 No. 8 DUAL Yes Yes
RB Clyde Edwards-Helaire (Jr.) 3 No. 5 APB No Yes
WR Justin Jefferson (Jr.) 3 No. 308 WR No Yes
LT Saahdiq Charles (Jr.) 4 No. 18 OG Yes Yes
LG Adrian McGee (RS-Sr.) 3 No. 45 OT No Yes
C Lloyd Cushenberry (RS-Jr.) 3 No. 82 OG No Yes
RG Damien Lewis (Sr.) 3 No. 2 OG (JUCO) No Yes
RT Austin Deculus (Jr.) 4 No. 10 OT Yes Yes
TE Thaddeus Moss (RS-Jr.) 3 No. 17 TE No Yes
WR JaMarr Chase (So.) 4 No. 15 WR Yes Yes
WR Terrace Marshall (So.) 5 No. 3 WR Yes Yes
Total blue-chip starters on offense 5
Top 10 recruits on offense (position ranks) 3
Georgia starting defense (probable) Star rating Pos. rank Blue-chip Blue-chip reserves
DT Tyler Clark (Sr.) 4 No. 27 DT Yes Yes
NT Michael Barnett (R-Sr.) 4 No. 14 SDE Yes Yes
DE Malik Herring (Jr.) 4 No. 4 SDE Yes Yes
OLB Azeez Ojulari (R-Fr.) 4 No. 10 DE Yes Yes
MLB Tae Crowder (R-Sr.) 3 No. 221 WR No Yes
WLB Monty Rice (Jr.) 4 No. 18 ILB Yes Yes
CB Eric Stokes (R-So.) 3 No. 63 CB No Yes
S Richard LeCounte II (Jr.) 5 No. 2 S Yes Yes
S J.R. Reed (RS-Sr.) 3 No. 157 CB No Yes
CB D.J. Daniel (Jr.) 4 No. 2 CB (JUCO) Yes Yes
STAR Mark Webb (Jr.) 4 No. 21 WR Yes Yes
Total blue-chip starters on defense 8
Top 10 recruits on defense (position ranks) 3

Check the values from the above table.

It is highly ironic that this specific on-field matchup will still only feature six combined players which rated as a top 10 national recruit at their position coming out of high school.

The fact that LSU receiver Justin Jefferson (81, catches, 1,02 yards, 13 TDs) was not a true blue-chip recruit speaks to the inexact sciences of recruiting rankings. While the scouting accuracy for recruiting has never been better given the prevalence of college schemes and evaluation camps now common to high school football, nothing is absolute.

Of the 18 prospects with the 5-star ratings that Georgia has signed of late, there are only three or four of those that present a good chance to start on Saturday. Sometimes college football (elite coaching, player development, player work ethic traits for the good or bad) happen and those rankings serve as motivational chips for the other players on these rosters, too.

Georgia-LSU: The stories so far on Dawgnation

The post Georgia-LSU: Which team has the edge from the recruiting trail? appeared first on DawgNation.

Read More

News

  • A New York City program that relocates its homeless to other cities around the country is drawing fire from Marietta leaders who say they learned it was happening from a newspaper article. >> Read more trending news  Members of Marietta City Council say they want answers about how New York runs its Special One-Time Assistance program, which provides one year’s rent for eligible clients to relocate within the city, other New York state cities or other states. The program is the subject of a lawsuit filed Dec. 1 by the city of Newark, New Jersey, which is one of the destination cities for New York’s homeless. The lawsuit argues the program pressures desperate homeless to accept substandard housing conditions and that slumlords benefit from the city’s program that pays for a year’s rent with no checks on the living conditions. CNN has reported that New York City has agreed to temporarily suspend the program. Marietta City Councilwoman Michelle Cooper Kelly said at the City Council’s Nov. 26 work session that she was “astonished” when she read a recent article in The New York Post that cited city records indicate New York City has sent homeless families to 373 cities around the country including Marietta, Kennesaw and Smyrna. According to the Post report, two homeless New York residents have been sent to Smyrna, while Marietta and Kennesaw have received one each. Other metro cities where New York’s homeless were relocated include Atlanta, East Point, Decatur, Stone Mountain, Alpharetta, Loganville, Lilburn, Lawrenceville and Riverdale. The Post also reported that since the program started in 2017, New York has relocated 5,074 families, or 12,482 people, to other areas within the city, state or around the country. Clients must show proof of income and have the future ability to pay their rent based on an amount that does not exceed 50 percent of their income, according to the city’s website. No other details about eligibility, including whether clients have to have family or employment waiting in another city or state, were provided on New York City’s website about the program. Kelly said the cities which have received the relocated families, including Marietta, have not been made aware of the program. The Atlanta Journal-Constitution called and emailed New York City officials to get more details about the program, but no one with the city government responded to those requests. Kelly said Marietta and Cobb County do a great job taking care of homeless people who are already living in the county, and taking on “the plight of another state” is something Marietta is not equipped to do. “We don’t want to be the place where people are sending their homeless population,” she said. “We want them to be addressing their own needs, as we are doing ours.” Kelly wants the city to research what options it has, including whether it could ask New York City to alert Marietta when it plans to send a person to its jurisdiction. City Attorney Doug Haynie said his research won’t be a “quick fix,” but he expects to make a recommendation by January for council members to consider. Jennifer Bennett, a spokeswoman with the city of Smyrna, said its homeless population is “known to us” and the city is not aware of anyone from New York City who has relocated to its jurisdiction. Smyrna has about five people they’ve identified as homeless who live within the city limits. “Our police department keeps an eye out for their welfare and checks on them from time to time, especially when weather conditions are unfavorable,” she said. Cobb officials are concerned that the relocated homeless could place a strain on the county’s service agencies. Kaye Cagle, spokeswoman with MUST Ministries, the Cobb-based charity that provides services for the homeless, said no one on the nonprofit’s staff has had any contact with anyone who relocated to the area under New York’s program. Tyler Driver, executive director of The Extension in Marietta, also said his organization has not had any contact with clients who have come from New York. The Extension provides long-term residential treatment to homeless people battling addictions. New York City’s program sparked a debate among Marietta’s elected officials. Councilwoman Cheryl Richardson said the practice of one government sending homeless people to other jurisdictions is nothing new. In the 1990’s, Project Homeward Bound used funding from Fulton County to provide one-way bus tickets for homeless people to leave town as long as they could prove they had family or a job waiting at their final destination. The program initially required recipients to promise they would not return to Atlanta, but managers of the program later dropped that caveat. Richardson said she was concerned about infringing on another person’s constitutional right to move freely. “Stopping this is going to be impossible,” she said of New York’s program, adding she wasn’t sure if Marietta had the ability to require New York inform other cities of its actions. Councilman Reggie Copeland said the issue magnifies the crisis of homelessness around the country since cities like New York and Marietta are all grappling with homelessness. “It’s not just local, it’s global,” he said.
  • Ruiz Food Products is recalling certain El Monterey breakfast burritos for plastic contamination, officials said. >> Read more trending news  The company recalled 55,013 pounds of 12-count, value pack “El Monterey signature burritos with egg sausage and cheese with a best buy date of 1/15/2021, the U.S. Department of Agriculture said. Three consumers complained after noticing hard, white plastic in a burrito. There are no reports of injuries. Consumers should return or throw away the burritos if they have them.
  • The House Democrats announced two articles of impeachment against President Donald Trump Tuesday morning -- abuse of power and obstruction of Congress. >> Read more trending news  The process of marking up, debating, amending and rewriting the articles of impeachment, is expected to begin begin Wednesday by the Judiciary Committee. The charges, if approved, would then be sent to the Senate, where the Republican majority would be unlikely to convict Trump. The Associated Press contributed to this report. 
  • Crews spent Tuesday trying to rescue a manatee with a bicycle tire wrapped around its body at a Florida state park, WFTV reported. >> Read more trending news   Rescue efforts at Blue Spring State Park. were unsuccessful, but SeaWorld Orlando officials said they will continue to try to rescue the animal. If it is captured, the manatee would be taken to SeaWorld for treatment. The rescue team comprises the Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission, SeaWorld, the Save the Manatee Club and the Volusia County government.
  • All Saudi military trainees have been grounded indefinitely from flight training at air bases across the country after a deadly shooting by a member of the Saudi Royal Air Force at Naval Air Station Pensacola. There are 852 Saudi students across the country. More than 300 Saudi military trainees are stationed at three bases in Florida. >> Read more trending news  The restriction includes 140 students at the naval base in Pensacola; 35 at nearby Whiting Field; and another 128 students at Naval Air Station Mayport, The Associated Press reported. Classroom training will continue this week. Flight training for other students will also resume while military leaders examine the vetting process, The New York Times reported. An estimated 5,100 international students training at U.S. military installations will also be part of the review. The order is in an effort to ensure student safety as they recover from the trauma of the shooting. The Saudi shooter killed three members of the U.S. military and injured eight others before he was fatally shot. The Associated Press contributed to this report.
  • Depending on one’s perspective, pigeons wearing tiny cowboy hats is either an amusing sight or a terrible example of animal abuse. What’s undeniable is that two pigeons were spotted in a Las Vegas parking lot, wearing the miniature head gear. >> Read more trending news  Bobby Lee was heading to the grocery store Thursday when he saw the birds pecking the ground in a parking lot near a dumpster, The New York Times reported. Pigeons are not unusual in Las Vegas, but Lee pulled out his cellphone and began recording video when he noticed two birds with tiny hats -- one red, and one gray, KNVT reported. Lee posted the video to Facebook, the television station reported. The video has gone viral on Facebook and Twitter, the television station reported. “The birds have hats on, bro!” Lee, 26, can be heard during the 12-second video he originally posted on Facebook. “It got a lot of attention fast,” Lee told the Times. “The day after, I had a lot of news people texting me and people trying to buy my video.” Who would put hats on wild birds? Lee said he did not know, but he did say the Wrangler National Finals Rodeo was in town. But the Professional Rodeo Cowboys Association, which organizes the event, “had nothing to do with the pigeons wearing cowboy hats,” Scott Kaniewski, the editor of ProRodeo Sports News, told the Times. Animal welfare agencies contacted Lee, including Lofty Hopes, a bird rescue organization. The group asked him to be vigilant and report if any more birds had hats, the Times reported. Charles Walcott, a Cornell University ornithologist who has been studying pigeons for 30 years, viewed the video Tuesday and said the pigeons seemed to be OK despite the headwear, the Times reported. “I enjoyed the video,' Walcott told the newspaper. 'I just thought those pigeons with hats were cute. 'I think the thing that I would emphasize is I can’t see that it is causing any great harm to the pigeons. The hats are “certainly light enough. They look like happy pigeons to me. It is hard to know, of course, because they will not talk to us.”