ON AIR NOW

LISTEN NOW

Weather

cloudy-day
88°
Partly Cloudy
H 87° L 72°
  • cloudy-day
    88°
    Current Conditions
    Partly Cloudy. H 87° L 72°
  • cloudy-day
    73°
    Morning
    Partly Cloudy. H 87° L 72°
  • cloudy-day
    85°
    Afternoon
    Mostly Cloudy. H 88° L 72°
LISTEN
PAUSE
ERROR

Wsb news on-demand

00:00 | 00:00

LISTEN
PAUSE
ERROR

Wsb traffic on-demand

00:00 | 00:00

LISTEN
PAUSE
ERROR

Wsb weather on-demand

00:00 | 00:00

State & Regional Govt & Politics
Judge asked to toss death penalty case due to illegal jury selection
Close

Judge asked to toss death penalty case due to illegal jury selection

Judge asked to toss death penalty case due to illegal jury selection
Photo Credit: The Atlanta Journal-Constitution
On their list of potential jurors, prosecutors in the Timothy Foster murder trial made notations of “B” to denote black jurors. All were eventually struck, and an all-white jury found Foster guilty and sentenced him to death in 1987. His contention that the prosecution violated the Constitution by striking jury members based on their race will be heard by the U.S. Supreme Court on Monday. (AJC file)

Judge asked to toss death penalty case due to illegal jury selection

State capital defenders on Monday asked a judge to dismiss a murder case because Floyd County prosecutors illegally assembled an all-white jury to put a black man on death row and then covered up their misconduct for decades.

Timothy Tyrone Foster was found guilty 32 years ago of killing an elderly white woman in Floyd County. The case drew a rebuke from the U.S. Supreme Court, which in 2016 strongly criticized prosecutors for striking every possible African-American from Foster’s jury and then giving trumped-up explanations as to why they excluded them.

“This is a case where for 30 years the prosecution perpetrated a fraud on the court,” said Jerry Word, one of Foster’s attorneys and head of the state capital defender office. “Even to this day the prosecution doesn’t acknowledge the extent of its misconduct.”

Word asked Superior Court Judge William Sparks to either dismiss the murder case against Foster or bar prosecutors from seeking the death penalty if they retry him again.

Assistant District Attorney Kevin Salmon, who asked Sparks to deny the requests, sought to downplay what happened at Foster’s trial. The prosecution’s misconduct wasn’t as bad as “hiding evidence” or “manipulating witnesses,” and it does not justify the relief sought by Foster’s lawyers, Salmon said.

Bill Rankin/Bill Rankin's Legal Brief
Timothy Tyrone Foster
Close

Judge asked to toss death penalty case due to illegal jury selection

Photo Credit: Bill Rankin/Bill Rankin's Legal Brief
Timothy Tyrone Foster

The case is now before Sparks because after the Supreme Court’s ruling, Foster was granted a new trial and Floyd County prosecutors announced they would once again seek the death penalty against him. Prosecutors say Foster, then 18, sexually assaulted and strangled Queen Madge White, 79, at her home in August 1986.

In its 7-1 decision, the Supreme Court relied on notes prosecutors used during jury selection of Foster’s case, in which a “B” was put next to the name of each prospective black juror. On one sheet of paper, the state listed six people as “definite NO’s” for the jury — with the first five being the remaining African-Americans in the jury pool.

During Monday’s hearing, a former Floyd County prosecutor testified that District Attorney Stephen Lanier was determined to get an all-white jury in Foster’s case.

“It was well known in the office that Stephen Lanier would not put a black person on the jury,” said Harold Chambers, who worked for Lanier in the DA’s office from 1985 to 1991.

A few years before Foster’s trial, Lanier allowed an African-American minister to sit as a juror in a death-penalty trial, said Chambers, now a federal administrative law judge. The minister was the lone holdout in an 11-1 vote for a death sentence, and because there was no unanimous verdict the defendant got a life sentence.

HANDOUT
Atlanta attorney Stephen Bright outside the U.S. Supreme Court in November 2015. He was there to argue the Foster’s case. Bright prevailed and a new trial was ordered for Foster, (Bill Rankin/AJC)
Close

Judge asked to toss death penalty case due to racist jury selection

Photo Credit: HANDOUT
Atlanta attorney Stephen Bright outside the U.S. Supreme Court in November 2015. He was there to argue the Foster’s case. Bright prevailed and a new trial was ordered for Foster, (Bill Rankin/AJC)

“From that point on, it was Mr. Lanier’s position he would never put a black person on the jury,” Chambers said.

During Foster’s trial, Chambers said, he overhead a heated conversation between Lanier and Clayton Lundy, an African-American investigator for the DA’s office. It occurred as the lengthy jury selection process was winding down.

“They were arguing with each other,” Chambers testified. He then repeated what he heard.

“You have to put a black person on this jury,” Lundy said.

“I’m not going to do it,” Lanier replied.

Even though Lundy kept insisting, Lanier wouldn’t budge, Chambers said. “He kept saying it over and over: ‘No, I’m not going to do it. I’m not going to put a black person on this jury.’”

Lundy then told Lanier something that proved to be prophetic: “If you don’t put a black person on this jury, this is going to come back to haunt you.”

Lanier, who served as district attorney from 1985 to 1996, died last year. Lundy, who would later be convicted of accepting bribes from suspects for getting their charges dismissed, could not be reached for comment.

Foster’s trial took place after the Supreme Court’s 1986 ruled in Batson v. Kentucky that prosecutors could not strike jurors because of their race. The high court also said when there is a pattern of strikes being made along racial lines, prosecutors must give race-neutral reasons to justify them.

Chief Justice John Roberts, who wrote the Foster opinion, found Lanier’s justifications for striking some of the black jurors to be based on pretext. One African-American woman, for example, was “too young” because the prosecution team was looking “for older jurors that would not easily identify with the defendant,” Lanier had explained.

But that prospective black juror, Marilyn Garrett, was 34 and Foster was 19, wrote Roberts, who pointedly noted Lanier had allowed a 21-year-old white woman to sit on the jury.

Chambers suggested there may have been a method behind Lanier’s explanations.

After the Batson ruling came out, Chambers said, seminars were held for prosecutors with training to help them deal with the decision.

“Here’s a list of racially-neutral reasons you can offer to a judge,” Chambers recalled. “It was designed for prosecutors to exclude blacks and give a reason for it.”

Chambers said he decided to approach Foster’s lawyers after he heard the Supreme Court was considering the jury misconduct claims.

“It was about as clear a Batson violation as I’ve ever seen in my life,” he said. “An egregious violation.”

Sparks said he would issue a ruling in the case sometime soon.

Timothy Tyrone Foster murder case

  • In 1987, Foster was convicted and sentenced to death for sexually assaulting and strangling a Rome woman inside her home.
  • In 2016, the U.S. Supreme ruled Floyd County prosecutors illegally excluded all potential African-American jurors from the trial and then gave trumped-up explanations to try and justify it. The decision led to Foster winning a new trial.
  • On Monday, a Floyd County judge held a hearing on a motion by capital defenders who want the case against Foster dismissed on prosecutorial misconduct grounds.

Read More

News

  • Dish and Sling subscribers in metro Atlanta without an over-the-air antenna have been missing CBS46 (WGCL-TV) the past few days and they might lose Fox Sports South and Fox Sports Southeast, as well, on Monday. >> Read more trending news   Dish, which has often been the most aggressive in negotiating with cable and broadcast networks among service providers, is currently at an impasse with all regional Fox Sports networks, recently purchased from 21st Century Fox by Disney. Dish and other providers pay fees to owners of channels and pass those costs on to consumers. Most of the time, those deals are negotiated behind the scenes. Every so often, networks decide to play hardball by publicizing the dispute and occasionally pulling off blackouts in hopes viewers would blame the service provider. Fox Sports South and Fox Sports Southeast are the primary carriers of Atlanta Braves games, airing 154 this year. Dish subscribers would miss out on games starting Tuesday, July 23 with a two-game series against the Kansas City Royals followed by a three-game against the Philadelphia Phillies and three more with the Washington Nationals. The Braves are currently leading the National League East. A spokesman for Fox Sports regional networks declined to comment but the networks have been posting ads on Facebook with the headline “Keep My Home Teams” and featuring a phone number and website.  Dish provided this statement:  “DISH’s goal is to keep these channels available to our customers. We are unsure why Disney, the new owner of these channels, decided to involve customers in the contract negotiation process at a point when there is still time for the two parties to reach a mutually beneficial deal.” Dish had a previous conflict with Fox Sports that lasted from 2013 to 2015 and kept 50 weekend Atlanta Braves off the air over three seasons. Why did that happen In 2013? Fox Sports bought the rights for games that were originally set to air on Peachtree TV and asked for extra money from the cable and satellite carriers. Everyone said fine – except Dish. Dish has said Fox was asking for too much for rights. Fox didn't budge until 2016. Meanwhile, in the other current Dish dispute, Meredith Corp., owner of several TV stations, including CBS46, decided to pull its stations off Dish Tuesday and a resolution has not happened yet as of Saturday night. 
  • A man was hitting his wife Sunday morning when he was shot by her son, officials said. >> Read more trending news   Harris County deputies said the 17-year-old shot his stepfather around 2:20 a.m. while the man was beating the boy’s mother, KPRC reported.  The stepfather was flown to a hospital for treatment. His condition is unknown.  It is unclear if the teen will face any charges, KPRC reported. 
  • A dispute between a Georgia lawmaker and a man she accused of verbally attacking her in a Cobb County store dominated headlines over the weekend.  State Rep. Erica Thomas, who is serving her second term representing an Austell-based district and as vice chair of her caucus is one of the state’s top Democrats,  posted a tearful Facebook video on Friday afternoon. The African American resident discussed her encounter with a white man at an express lane at Publix in Mableton.  He took exception that Thomas, who is nine months pregnant, was flouting the 10 items or less rule.  'This white man comes up to me and says, 'You lazy son of (expletive). You need to go back where you came from,'' she posted. 'Sir, you don't even know me. I'm not lazy. I'm nine months pregnant.' At this point in the video, she’s bawling as she dabs her eyes with a tissue. “Yes, I had 15 items but I’m nine months pregnant, and I can’t stand up for long,” she said. The video has been viewed over 117,000 times since it was first posted and amassed nearly 3,000 comments.  Within hours, Kathy Griffin and other celebrities tweeted #IStandWithErica.  Teresa Tomlinson, a U.S. Senate candidate, said “all sane people of good conscience” support Thomas.  Many called on Publix, which said Saturday it was cooperating with local authorities, to release a tape of the incident. The company has not yet said whether it will — or whether one even exists.  In a statement released Saturday, the supermarket chain said, “At Publix we are committed to creating a safe and welcoming shopping experience for all our customers.” A day after the incident, during a planned interview at the store with Channel 2 Action News, Thomas found herself face to face again with the man she accused of verbally attacking her. Eric Sparkes, who had also reached out to the news station, had shown up to talk to the store’s management about the incident. With Thomas standing a few feet away, Sparkes said he noticed she had about 20 items at the express lane and when he turned to her to complain, she “berated” him. He then said he laced into her. “I stated, ‘You’re a selfish little (expletive).’ I did say that. That’s all I said after that and I walked out of Publix. Her words stating on Twitter, and her video, stating I told her she needs to go back where she came from are untrue. I am Cuban.” In a subsequent interview with Channel 2, Thomas said, “I don't want to say he said, ‘Go back to your country,’ or ‘Go back to where you came from.’ But he was making those types of references is what I remember.” MORE: Trump’s ‘go back’ attacks roil Georgia politics The incident came days after President Donald Trump’s remarks that four liberal congresswomen should “go back” to their home countries — and after a Gwinnett County Democratic activist had a nasty run-in with a Trump supporter at a grocery store on the other side of Atlanta’s suburbs. The blowback for Trump was immediate, as both Democratic and Republican politicians labeled the tweets as “inappropriate” and “racist.”  In the Thomas incident, some Republican sleuthing revealed Sparkes had made critical comments on social media about Trump, leading them to believe he was a Democrat. Republicans also criticized Thomas and other Democrats for sending out a fundraising plea on the incident that asserted “no woman should be subjected to this type of behavior from anyone while living their lives.”  The Georgia GOP had some of the harshest words: “Raising money on fabricated stories, lies and false narratives. Just business as usual for the Georgia Democrat Party and those they put in office.”  The state Democratic Party and other leading Georgia Democrats, meanwhile, have tweeted their support for Thomas and her side of the story. “You keep lying,” Thomas said in a tweet Saturday night directed at Sparkes, “we have witnesses that will testify!”
  • The reign of 'Avatar' as the top-grossing film of all time is over after a decade. 'Avengers: Endgame' has toppled James Cameron's sci-fi movie to become the highest-grossing box office film in the world.  Variety reported that the Disney and Marvel blockbuster has made more than $2.7902 billion at the global box office Sunday, surpassing the $2.7897 billion gross for 'Avatar.' The announcement was made at San Diego Comic-Con on Saturday afternoon, according to The Hollywood Reporter. >> Read more trending news  “A huge congratulations to the Marvel Studios and Walt Disney Studios teams, and thank you to the fans around the world who lifted Avengers: Endgame to these historic heights,' Disney Studios co-chairman and chief creative officer Alan Horn said in a statement. 'Of course, even with the passage of a decade, the impact of James Cameron’s 'Avatar' remains as powerful as ever, and the astonishing achievements of both of these films are ongoing proof of the power of movies to move people and bring them together in a shared experience. The talented filmmakers behind these worlds have much more in store, and we look forward to the future of both the Marvel Cinematic Universe and Pandora.” In June, 'Endgame' returned to theaters with about six minutes of new footage in an effort to dethrone 'Avatar.' It was initially released in theaters in April. The news comes after a slate of new Marvel projects were announced at Comic-Con. A new ensemble franchise, 'Eternals,' was announced, with Richard Madden, Kumail Nanjiani, Lauren Ridloff, Brian Tyree Henry, Salma Hayek, Lia McHugh, Don Lee and Angelina Jolie. Marvel dominates half of the top 10 highest-grossing films in the world. A list of the top 10 all-time worldwide box office grosses is below. 'Avengers: Endgame' - $2.7902 billion 'Avatar' - $2.7897 billion 'Titanic' - $2.1875 billion 'Star Wars: The Force Awakens' - $2.0682 billion 'Avengers: Infinity War' - $2.0484 billion 'Jurassic World' - $1.6717 billion 'Marvel's The Avengers' - $1.5188 billion 'Furious 7' - $1.5160 billion 'Avengers: Age of Ultron' - $1.4054 billion 'Black Panther' - $1.3469 billion
  • One person was struck by lightning and seven others nearby were also injured by the impact Sunday, officials said.  >> Read more trending news  A group of people was at Clearwater Beach near Frenchy’s Rockaway restaurant when a man was struck by lightning around 12:42 p.m., causing him to have a heart attack, officials said.  He was taken to a hospital and is in critical condition, officials said. Another person was taken to a hospital with burn injuries. Three others were taken to a hospital with unknown injuries. Another three people refused transport. Lifeguards had left their towers around 12:30 p.m. as severe thunderstorms began to roll through the area.  “Beachgoers should take cover and go to a safe place when lightning and thunder are present,” officials said.
  • The carcass of a minke whale washed up along a Massachusetts beach Friday.  >> Read more trending news   They are not endangered or threatened but the species of whale is part of an unusual mortality event since 2017, with 59 documented deaths along the Atlantic coast from Maine to South Carolina, according to the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Fisheries. They are protected under the Marine Mammal Protection Act. Heavy equipment was needed to move the 23-foot marine mammal, considered a young adult, the Cape Cod Times reported. Minke are the smallest of what are considered the great whales. They grow up to 35 feet and weigh up to 20,000 pounds. Their common name comes from a Norwegian whaling spotter named “Meincke” who mistook a minke whale for a blue whale.  A necropsy will be performed Monday.