Coronavirus:

What You Need To Know

On Air Now

Listen Now

Weather

cloudy-day
83°
Clear
H 85° L 62°
  • cloudy-day
    83°
    Current Conditions
    Clear. H 85° L 62°
  • clear-day
    85°
    Today
    Clear. H 85° L 62°
  • clear-day
    82°
    Tomorrow
    Mostly Clear. H 82° L 62°
Listen
Pause
Error

News on-demand

00:00 | 00:00

Listen
Pause
Error

Traffic on-demand

00:00 | 00:00

Listen
Pause
Error

Weather on-demand

00:00 | 00:00

State & Regional Govt & Politics
Georgia EPD doubted ethylene oxide cancer risks. Other states acted.
Close

Georgia EPD doubted ethylene oxide cancer risks. Other states acted.

Georgia EPD doubted ethylene oxide cancer risks. Other states acted.
Photo Credit: The Atlanta Journal-Constitution
Jenni Shover holds a sign during a protest against the Sterigenics plant held Aug. 29 at the nearby intersection of Atlanta and Plant Atkinson roads. “I didn’t sign up to be anybody’s lab rat,” she told the AJC recently, “but that’s what I am.” ALYSSA POINTER / ALYSSA.POINTER@AJC.COM

Georgia EPD doubted ethylene oxide cancer risks. Other states acted.

When Colorado environmental regulators received a federal report that warned of potential cancer risks in communities near Denver in August 2018, they alerted the public and the media and vowed to find out what residents were breathing.

Two days after the information became public, the state started air testing for ethylene oxide, the cancer-causing compound used by a medical sterilization company that the federal Environmental Protection Agency identified as the culprit of the possible health threat. Within a month, Colorado officials had persuaded the company to enact new pollution controls, and a second round of air tests in October, after the upgrades, showed a dramatic reduction in concentrations of the toxic gas.

By October, the Illinois attorney general had sued a suburban Chicago company to curb emissions, and a month later Michigan started testing the air around one of its ethylene oxide emitters.

When confronted with the EPA’s National Air Toxics Assessment (NATA) at exactly the same time as Colorado, Illinois and Michigan, Georgia regulators decided not to publicize the EPA’s report and rejected as unreliable the idea of air testing, according to an Atlanta Journal-Constitution review of more than 22,000 emails and other documents.

The Georgia Environmental Protection Division also kept the NATA report from then-Gov. Nathan Deal and incoming Gov. Brian Kemp, according to interviews with state officials, despite state law that says the agency has a duty to counsel the governor on environmental concerns affecting the state.

By the time Colorado had convinced its medical sterilization plant to enact pollution controls, records show, Georgia was still three months away from even meeting with the operators of two metro Atlanta sterilizers that were also emitting potentially dangerous levels of the cancer-causing gas according to the EPA’s 2018 assessment.

After site visits at the plants at the end of 2018, Georgia EPD waited for months for the two plants to produce data so that the state could conduct its own analysis using mathematical modeling, which Georgia only completed in June.

The Atlanta Journal-Constitution
The exterior of the Cobb County Sterigenics plant near Smyrna in Cobb County. Cobb County recently ordered the plant closed until it can comply with safety measures. ALYSSA POINTER / ALYSSA.POINTER@AJC.COM
Close

Georgia EPD doubted ethylene oxide cancer risks. Other states acted.

Photo Credit: The Atlanta Journal-Constitution
The exterior of the Cobb County Sterigenics plant near Smyrna in Cobb County. Cobb County recently ordered the plant closed until it can comply with safety measures. ALYSSA POINTER / ALYSSA.POINTER@AJC.COM

The AJC’s review of Georgia’s response to the ethylene oxide crisis also found that state regulators appeared to miss the big picture — that the federal EPA now considered the risk of ethylene oxide exposure to be many times greater than before and that the public deserved to know. The agency’s narrow thinking and slow response contributed to a public panic in July when online health care publications broke the news about the potential health threat, the AJC found.

Once the risk became public, Georgia reversed course and committed to air testing around the plants. Gov. Kemp quickly secured pledges of enhanced pollution controls at both of the ethylene oxide emitters in metro Atlanta — Sterigenics near Smyrna in Cobb County and Becton Dickinson (BD) in Covington.

But those actions came a year after those taken in Colorado and Illinois, and eight months after proactive measures in Michigan, all states that EPA flagged for ethylene oxide risks.

“I feel betrayed,” said Smyrna homeowner Jenni Shover, who took part in a protest this summer holding up a sign that read, “Hell hath no fury like a woman poisoned.”

“They made a conscious decision not to tell the public,” Shover said. “There is no trust with them.”

At town halls in Marietta and Covington in August, Georgia regulators presented new modeling that showed risks from ethylene oxide, or EtO, were less acute, confined to the immediate vicinity of the plants and not in surrounding neighborhoods. They also announced that both plants would invest millions to upgrade their emissions controls.

But many residents aren’t buying it.

“We need independent testing to get the facts,” Jason McCarthy, who leads a Covington-area chapter of the group called Stop EtO, said at one town hall. “We need independent testing to repair the trust that was broken.”

The Atlanta Journal-Constitution
Earlier this year the BD plant in Covington, seen here, told state regulators that it was emitting far less ethylene oxide than what its prior operator reported to the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency. Nevertheless, modeling by the Georgia Environmental Protection Division showed that areas in the immediate vicinity of both BD and Sterigenics had EtO emissions greater than EPA’s safety thresholds. ALYSSA POINTER / ALYSSA.POINTER@AJC.COM
Close

Georgia EPD doubted ethylene oxide cancer risks. Other states acted.

Photo Credit: The Atlanta Journal-Constitution
Earlier this year the BD plant in Covington, seen here, told state regulators that it was emitting far less ethylene oxide than what its prior operator reported to the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency. Nevertheless, modeling by the Georgia Environmental Protection Division showed that areas in the immediate vicinity of both BD and Sterigenics had EtO emissions greater than EPA’s safety thresholds. ALYSSA POINTER / ALYSSA.POINTER@AJC.COM

Georgia EPD Director Richard Dunn and other officials stand by their handling of the ethylene oxide controversy. They said they thought from the outset that the 2018 report from EPA grossly overstated ethylene oxide dangers, a view shared by many EtO emitters, and required a deeper ground-level assessment.

“The driver of our thinking was this is a screening tool, and we need further study,” Dunn said. “That was the sole driver.”

Kemp spokeswoman Candice Broce said EPD will be more forthcoming with the public in the future. The NATA report has been online since 2018, but with EPD being “a very scientific branch of government,” they didn’t recognize a need for public relations, she said.

“It wasn’t that they didn’t take any action, it’s that they didn’t publicize it in a way people would have expected,” Broce said. “And they’ve changed that practice. They’re moving forward, trying to be as clear as possible with press releases and public hearings, to be transparent and get tough questions from the community.”

Failure to communicate

The state had plenty of time to craft a regulatory and communications response, the AJC found.

In summer 2017, Georgia regulators got an early peek at the EPA’s findings, which suggested two Atlanta-area plants might be emitting harmful levels of ethylene oxide, an invisible, odorless gas that had been reclassified as a carcinogen in the final days of the Obama administration. Federal officials told states not to share its “draft results” with anyone outside of their agencies.

A Georgia modeling and data manager at the time reviewed the preliminary findings and sent an email to an EPA air quality official, saying she didn’t understand “strange hot spots” in Newton and Cobb counties. The EPA official responded that the risk factor for ethylene oxide “went up by about a factor of 60.”

The exchange triggered some internal discussion within EPD, but no deeper investigation.

In the final NATA report, the areas of risk shifted slightly. But neighborhoods around the Sterigenics and BD plants remained on the list of ethylene oxide hot spots.

EPA distributed talking points to state agencies, including Georgia EPD, but opted against issuing a press release.

Karen Hays, the director of the Georgia EPD’s air protection branch, said she did not recall agency leaders having any discussions about informing the public.

“As far as communication, trying to communicate something that is this complicated is really challenging for us because there is a lot of information that is quite frankly contradictory,” she said. “To take what’s in the NATA and spread it out to the public without doing a detailed evaluation of what’s really happening, to me, is just not appropriate.”

SIPA USA VIA AP IMAGES
Terumo BCT, in Lakewood, Colorado, took steps to reduce its ethylene oxide emissions within a month of the release of a federal report warning of elevated cancer risks. KRISTOFFER TRIPPLAAR / SIPA USA VIA AP IMAGES
Close

Georgia EPD doubted ethylene oxide cancer risks. Other states acted.

Photo Credit: SIPA USA VIA AP IMAGES
Terumo BCT, in Lakewood, Colorado, took steps to reduce its ethylene oxide emissions within a month of the release of a federal report warning of elevated cancer risks. KRISTOFFER TRIPPLAAR / SIPA USA VIA AP IMAGES

Colorado: ‘reassure the public’

Colorado, Illinois and Michigan had no such qualms about releasing information, the AJC found.

Colorado regulators issued a press release the same day the federal report was made public, Aug. 22, 2018, linking to EPA’s website and describing the state’s plans for dealing with the Denver-area plant, Terumo BCT.

“Measuring actual exposures, rather than computer-modeled exposure as in the EPA analysis, will provide a more accurate picture of whether there is a potential health risk,” the press release from the Colorado Department of Public Health and Environment said.

The announcement said that even though Terumo BCT was in compliance with state and federal pollution control requirements, and even though the state’s own cancer registry showed no elevation in cases near the plant, the first round of air sampling would be done within a month.

Testing started two days later — lasting seven days with samples taken from four sites around the plant. The results backed up what the federal report’s modeling showed — air concentrations that well exceeded the EPA’s cancer danger threshold.

“We knew that once (NATA) went out, people were going to see it, and we would get questions on it,” said Gordon Pierce, a program manager in the Colorado’s air pollution control division. “So if we didn’t have answers or have work ongoing to try and get answers, we would be called to task on it.”

Pierce said his department could have relied on computer modeling alone to evaluate the cancer risks, the approach taken in Georgia, but that might not have satisfied people living nearby.

Colorado tested the air again for seven days in October 2018, after Terumo BCT installed new pollution controls. This time samples were taken at eight points, including as far as a mile away. The tests found a 2- to 5-fold reduction in cancer risk, although it remained above the EPA’s acceptable range for ethylene oxide. Pierce said he’s waiting for guidance from EPA on what to do next.

“It was to reassure the public,” Pierce said. “It was also to make sure that what we were being told by the company matched.”

After an open house to explain the testing results to residents, publicity subsided and the state had the issue behind them by Christmas.

Excluding staff time, the air sampling cost Colorado $23,000, according to a department spokeswoman.

The Atlanta Journal-Constitution
Georgia’s Environmental Protection Division has agreed to conduct long-term air testing near two plants that emit ethylene oxide, including BD in Covington, seen here. Residents say that because the state didn’t test sooner, they’ll never know what the plants were pumping out before regulatory scrutiny began. ALYSSA POINTER / ALYSSA.POINTER@AJC.COM
Close

Georgia EPD doubted ethylene oxide cancer risks. Other states acted.

Photo Credit: The Atlanta Journal-Constitution
Georgia’s Environmental Protection Division has agreed to conduct long-term air testing near two plants that emit ethylene oxide, including BD in Covington, seen here. Residents say that because the state didn’t test sooner, they’ll never know what the plants were pumping out before regulatory scrutiny began. ALYSSA POINTER / ALYSSA.POINTER@AJC.COM

Illinois, Michigan also act

In the Chicago suburb of Willowbrook, federal scientists were so alarmed by emissions modeling at a Sterigenics facility that the agency conducted its own air sampling, months before the NATA report’s publication. EPA also called in a specialized division of the Atlanta-based Centers for Disease Control and Prevention to assess the results.

Based on preliminary modeling and air testing, the CDC specialists said ethylene oxide in the air posed “a public health hazard to these populations.”

The NATA report and the Willowbrook air tests were released together in August 2018, triggering organized protests and a series of angry public meetings. By October, the state attorney general and DuPage County sued Sterigenics to curb emissions.

After the Village of Willowbrook conducted its own air tests in February, which showed high levels of the gas, the state temporarily closed the plant until it could meet strict new standards. Last month, Sterigenics announced the plant will not reopen.

“We’re going to be done up here by the time you guys get started (air testing),” Willowbrook Mayor Frank Trilla told the AJC last month. “By the time you get done, they’re going to have shutters on their doors.”

Georgia’s air quality regulators watched the Willowbrook controversy unfold, swapping news stories about heated public meetings and sharing the federal air testing report, emails show. That still didn’t spur anyone to craft a communications strategy.

MARK BLACK / FOR THE AJC
Incensed about ethylene oxide emissions in Willowbrook, Ill., more than 100 protesters rallied in front of Sterigenics’ headquarters in September 2018. In Georgia, state regulators swapped emails about the brewing controversy. MARK BLACK / FOR THE AJC
Close

Georgia EPD doubted ethylene oxide cancer risks. Other states acted.

Photo Credit: MARK BLACK / FOR THE AJC
Incensed about ethylene oxide emissions in Willowbrook, Ill., more than 100 protesters rallied in front of Sterigenics’ headquarters in September 2018. In Georgia, state regulators swapped emails about the brewing controversy. MARK BLACK / FOR THE AJC

The records show EPD officials taking a skeptical view of Illinois’ enforcement efforts. A risk assessment program manager downplayed the air testing, writing in an email that “my concern … is the assumption that a casual relationship can be easily drawn between chronic exposure to EtO air emissions and elevated cancers in the population surrounding a facility under routine monitoring.”

Observing the Willowbrook controversy from across Lake Michigan, however, the Michigan Department of Environment, Great Lakes and Energy wanted no such firestorm on its watch.

Three months after NATA posted, Michigan conducted air tests around its most problematic plant, Viant Medical in Grand Rapids. The neighborhood had already been on the department’s radar because of a possible cancer cluster believed to be linked to an old city dump.

But with outrage building in Willowbrook, Michigan went forward with a press release in January, announcing Michigan had issued Viant Medical a violation notice for failing to control its ethylene oxide emissions, according to Chris Ethridge, a field operations manager for the Michigan’s air quality division.

“We had measurements that were of concern, so we felt compelled to notify the community,” Ethridge said. “I think it’s kind of a matter of ethics.”

A second round of air testing in March found emissions levels still above state standards. The company has announced that it will halt its sterilizing operations at the plant by the end of the year, characterizing it as a business decision. Under a proposed consent order, the company faces a $110,000 fine for its emissions.

The Atlanta Journal-Constitution
The Georgia Environmental Protection Division did its first round of ambient air testing in June at its South DeKalb County site, seen here. Because of public outcry, the agency has also installed monitors to test the air near sterilizing plants in Cobb and Newton counties. Meanwhile, Smyrna, Cobb County and Atlanta are paying for their own testing at a cost of $130,000. J. SCOTT TRUBEY / STRUBEY@AJC.COM
Close

Georgia EPD doubted ethylene oxide cancer risks. Other states acted.

Photo Credit: The Atlanta Journal-Constitution
The Georgia Environmental Protection Division did its first round of ambient air testing in June at its South DeKalb County site, seen here. Because of public outcry, the agency has also installed monitors to test the air near sterilizing plants in Cobb and Newton counties. Meanwhile, Smyrna, Cobb County and Atlanta are paying for their own testing at a cost of $130,000. J. SCOTT TRUBEY / STRUBEY@AJC.COM

Air testing dismissed

EPD defended computer modeling as being more scientifically sound than air testing, but experts told the AJC modeling should be buttressed by testing data around emission sources.

Modeling analyzes companies’ self-reported emissions, building and smokestack dimensions, and years of meteorological data to estimate where gases go and plot areas of potential exposure.

Monitoring samples the air to determine what compounds are present and in what amounts. There are drawbacks: it can take months and may not pinpoint the exact sources of a chemical.

But air testing can be used to check whether the modeling and self-reported company data match the physical conditions in the air.

“It’s good to verify your model with observations,” said Jennifer Kaiser, a Georgia Tech assistant professor in environmental engineering and atmospheric sciences. “Testing is sort of ground truth.”

The federal EPA says air testing has discovered ethylene oxide in higher concentrations than expected and in places where scientists hadn’t forecasted.

Industry groups contend air sampling fails to take into account background levels of ethylene oxide produced by vehicle emissions and other natural sources. They also say the EPA’s risk level for the compound is too strict, lower in fact than what is naturally made within the human body.

The Atlanta Journal-Constitution
When the Georgia Environmental Protection Division did its first round of ambient air testing in South DeKalb County, using the monitoring device seen here, the ethylene oxide reading was 15 times higher than what is deemed acceptable by federal regulators, despite being miles away from any known source. J. SCOTT TRUBEY / STRUBEY@AJC.COM
Close

Georgia EPD doubted ethylene oxide cancer risks. Other states acted.

Photo Credit: The Atlanta Journal-Constitution
When the Georgia Environmental Protection Division did its first round of ambient air testing in South DeKalb County, using the monitoring device seen here, the ethylene oxide reading was 15 times higher than what is deemed acceptable by federal regulators, despite being miles away from any known source. J. SCOTT TRUBEY / STRUBEY@AJC.COM

Georgia EPD echoed some of those arguments, saying in an interview that early test results in Illinois were invalidated because other chemicals collected by sampling canisters skewed the data.

Dika Kuoh, Georgia’s assistant air protection branch chief, said the science of ethylene oxide air testing hadn’t been perfected when EPA published the NATA report in August 2018. Federal regulators released air testing guidance only a few months ago.

“Modeling is always the first tool that’s used in these situations because it is the one that gives you the quickest result,” Kuoh said. “You go monitoring, you are just measuring the air, and you could be measuring all kinds of things that are not the facility or related to the facility.”

The Atlanta Journal-Constitution
Jenni Shover has been protesting the Sterigenics plant along with members of the Stop Sterigenics Georgia group. She says Georgia's air pollution regulators should have started air testing as soon as they knew about elevated cancer risks. ALYSSA POINTER / ALYSSA.POINTER@AJC.COM
Close

Georgia EPD doubted ethylene oxide cancer risks. Other states acted.

Photo Credit: The Atlanta Journal-Constitution
Jenni Shover has been protesting the Sterigenics plant along with members of the Stop Sterigenics Georgia group. She says Georgia's air pollution regulators should have started air testing as soon as they knew about elevated cancer risks. ALYSSA POINTER / ALYSSA.POINTER@AJC.COM

Public outrage when the health risks became known, however, forced EPD to rethink this position two months ago, agreeing to conduct long-term testing near both plants.

“I will say this, from my perspective, the monitoring is due to demands from the community,” EPD Director Dunn said. “It’s less so from a scientific perspective.”

Shover, who protested Sterigenics in August, has been living near the plant for nearly two decades. She says Georgia already squandered its chance to find out what the two plants were pumping out before they knew they were under scrutiny. With every ache, pain and itch, she said she worries about cancer.

“We will never have that data — never,” Shover said. “And that is unforgivable.”

Staff Writer Meris Lutz contributed to this story.

Facilities using ethylene oxide in Georgia

Sterigenics, Smyrna

Sterilization Services of Georgia, South Fulton

BD (Becton, Dickinson and Company), Madison

BD (Becton, Dickinson and Company), Covington

Kendall Patient Recovery, Augusta

Stepan, Winder

Anewmed, Tucker

Innovative Chemical Technologies, Cartersville

Source: Georgia Environmental Protection Division

Timeline of ethylene oxide regulation

December 2016: Ethylene oxide, or EtO, a gas used to sterilize medical equipment, is reclassified as a known carcinogen by EPA.

June 2017: EPA shares preliminary results of its National Air Toxics Assessment (NATA) report with states, including Georgia.

August 2017: Georgia EPD officials note “hot spots” near Georgia medical sterilization plants, including Sterigenics in Cobb and BD in Newton counties.

August 2018: EPA releases its NATA report indicating three Georgia census tracts near Sterigenics and BD that use EtO have the potential for high cancer risk; EPA and Georgia EPD do not publicize the findings.

June 14, 2019: Georgia starts first round of ambient air testing in South DeKalb County, miles from any known EtO source to get a fix on background levels. The reading is 15 times higher than what is deemed acceptable by federal regulators, while later tests find no detectable EtO.

July 19, 2019: NATA data publicized in Georgia by WebMd/Georgia Health News.

August 7, 2019: Georgia EPD enters into a consent order with sterilizer Sterigenics to improve emissions controls at its plant near Smyrna.

Early September: GHD, an international environmental consulting firm working for Smyrna, Cobb County and Atlanta, takes air samples near Sterigenics while plant operations are suspended. The tests find no detectable EtO in most samples, but one sample reading is 395 times above the federal threshold.

Late September and early October 2019: EPD installs monitors to test the air near Sterigenics and BD.

Source: Georgia Environmental Protection documents and AJC analysis.

Read More

News

  • Target will close dozens of its locations nationwide - including two in metro Atlanta, due to ongoing protests and destructive rioting in the wake of George Floyd’s death. In Georgia, two locations in Buckhead will temporarily close.  The chain’s headquarters are based in Minneapolis, where Floyd’s death occurred while in police custody.  now former officer Derek Chauvin is charged in Floyd’s death.   “We are heartbroken by the death of George Floyd and the pain it is causing communities across the country. At this time, we have made the decision to close a number of our stores. We anticipate most stores will be closed temporarily. Our focus will remain on our team members’ safety and helping our community heal,” the company said in a statement. Target says employees at the closed stores will be paid for up to 14 days during store closures, including coronavirus pay, and also have the chance to work at other stores. From Channel 2 Action News: During the first night of protests Friday, Atlanta firefighters worked to put out a fire started in the back of the Target at 2539 Piedmont Road. Atlanta fire officials say fireworks were set off in multiple locations as well. Atlanta firefighters worked to put a second fire that happened in a storage room Saturday night. The department can’t say for sure right now if it’s arson, but fire investigators are on the way to see. Atlanta Battalion Chief Kendale Mitchell said part of the building may have been left unsecured from Friday’s protests. “This store was broken into earlier when we were experiencing the protests and the store hasn’t been fully secured all the way. I think they have security on site but may or may not. It’s undetermined if it was a break in at this time or not,” Mitchell said.    
  • — Phil Collen, guitarist for the rock band Def Leppard, recently surprised a group of high school students who were tuned in for a virtual music lesson. Collen partnered with Yousician, a music education company, to join a Zoom class for music students at Long Island High School for the Arts in Syosset, New York. The 13 students didn’t know the British musician would be joining their lesson, Patch.com reported. Collen started by performing his band’s 1987 hit “Pour Some Sugar On Me.' He then allowed the students to play their own renditions of the hit song and offered feedback. Collen also talked about his music journey and offered advice to the aspiring musicians: “It really comes down to putting the effort in, practicing and getting the technique down,' he said. “It’s all a learning curve. You gotta be you.” According to Patch.com, the students were granted free access to the Yousician platform to continue developing their musical skills over the summer. The students will also receive a free signed Def Leppard shirt.
  • Protesters who took to the streets angry about the death of George Floyd in Minneapolis voiced their outrage and frustration but remained peaceful for hours before the violence erupted. At one point on Saturday, protesters in a group in Washington state started to approach a line of Seattle police, but organizers called the crowd back and urged them to protest peacefully. “[We’re] not thugs, [we’re] activists looking for change,” one protester said, according to KIRO-TV. Before things turned destructive, speakers shared their message, urging everyone to stand up to racism. But as frustration turned to violence, those who remained peaceful worried the message that brought them to the streets would be lost. “I’m out here to protest, not to burn our city. Not to throw rocks at these businesses who supported us all these years,” another protester told KIRO-TV. “I shouldn’t have to worry every day about every black man I know. But no. No destruction. Change,” Washington resident Anika Jones said. After the growing chaos led Seattle Mayor Jenny Durkan to declare a civil emergency and announce a curfew for the entire city, a move that has been enforced in many cities nationwide, Durkan thanked those who protested without violence. 'I know the vast majority of today's demonstrators came together with the intention to protest, grieve, and commit themselves to justice. For most of today, the demonstrations were peaceful, and I thank all those who chose to exercise their right to protest without hurting others,” Durkan said. Cyrus Habib, Lt. Gov. of Washington, also thanked those who protested peacefully and reminded people that violence only takes away from their message. “To those engaging in the destruction of property -- enough. Violence undermines our cause and begets more violence, distracting from the point,” Habib wrote on Twitter. Some protesters have echoed that sentiment. “This isn’t helping anyone. This is not about George Floyd,' an activist told KIRO-TV. “This is about stealing, and it’s sad because it diminishes the real issue.”
  • Congressman John Lewis criticized the looting and violence that followed peaceful protests in Atlanta and other cities, a position that is bringing him praise and accusations that the Civil Rights-era activist is out of touch.  “We must continue to teach the way of peace, the way of love, the philosophy and the discipline of non-violence,” he said on MSNBC Saturday evening. “And never, ever give up on any of our brothers and sisters. We’re one people; we’re one family. “  Lewis, 80, posted a longer statement on his U.S. House website directly addressing protesters.  “To the rioters here in Atlanta and across the country: I see you, and I hear you,” he wrote. “I know your pain, your rage, your sense of despair and hopelessness. Justice has, indeed, been denied for far too long. Rioting, looting, and burning is not the way. Organize. Demonstrate. Sit-in. Stand-up. Vote. Be constructive, not destructive. History has proven time and again that non-violent, peaceful protest is the way to achieve the justice and equality that we all deserve.” Read more: ‘Atlanta Way’ challenged after violent night of protests A post on Twitter excerpting his statement was shared by Republican U.S. Sen. Ted Cruz, celebrity chef Padma Lakshmi and former Maryland Gov. Martin O’Malley among others thanking Lewis for speaking out.  While there were many people praising the congressman, who was badly beaten during a march across Selma’s Pettus Bridge in 1965 and is considered one of the last living Civil Rights leaders, others said he wasn’t fully acknowledging that previous protests often turned violent because of police brutality and that it, along with racism and economic inequality, continue to persist.  User @RykerStevenson replied: “I love you, you are a hero in my family but we have organized, sat in, stood up, voted. We’ve been doing that for decades. Maybe what the country needs is to know that if you murder a black man in the street then every street in major cities across the country will burn.”  Another person on Twitter, @SmizeEyes, wrote: “Look how well that approach turned out for Martin Luther King Jr. & you. I’m sure you still feel the mental & physical scars from that.” The protests, which swept across Atlanta for the past two nights, are sparked by outrage over the police killing of George Floyd in Minneapolis. Marchers have also voiced concerns about the death of Breonna Taylor, who was killed when police in Louisville, Ky., erroneously executed a search on her home. The shooting death of Ahmaud Arbery in Brunswick, especially prosecutors’ conduct in that case, has also been criticized.  All of this is happening while many feel the effects of the COVID-19 pandemic, which has led to job losses and limitations on daily life that affected African-Americans and other people of color more deeply.  “But what do you do when you've tried all those things and nothing has changed?” Christina M. Brooks wrote. “Trump and the Republicans sit on legislation or ignore it. Booth for gun control and civil rights. They revoke laws that even in a remedial way try to level the playing field. What more can people do?” Several said non-violent protests have proven ineffective.  Despite disagreement with Lewis’s statements, people who appeared to be condescending or disrespectful toward the congressman were generally rebuked.  Complete coverage: Atlanta protests Lewis’s MSNBC interview: 
  • The manned SpaceX docked with the International Space Station on Sunday morning, a day after the rocket lifted off and sent two astronauts into space for the first time from the U.S. in almost a decade. Veteran astronauts Doug Hurley and Bob Behnken flew in the first launch of astronauts by a private company, docking at 10:16 a.m. EDT 18 hours, 58 minutes after Saturday’s launch. Before opening the hatch and entering the station, Behnken and Hurley will conduct a series of pressure and leak checks to ensure their safety. Then they will join NASA astronaut Chris Cassidy and two Russian cosmonauts aboard the station, The Washington Post reported. The spacecraft made its rendezvous with the space station, which was traveling in an orbit at 17,500 mph, the newspaper reported. The mission went smoothly, ground officials said, after Saturday’s launch was witnessed by a crowd that included President Donald Trump.
  • Editor’s note: This story has been updated.  Atlanta Mayor Keisha Lance Bottoms on Sunday extended the city’s curfew, which will take effect at 9 p.m. and continue until sunrise Monday. Bottoms instituted the curfew Saturday in the wake of a violent protest on Friday that led to damage at businesses and attractions in downtown Atlanta and Buckhead.  The announcement came about noon and a few hours after Bottoms said in national television interviews that 157 people were arrested in protests that again turned violent Saturday night.  The curfew extension was announced on the city’s official Facebook page.  In her Sunday morning interviews on CBS and NBC, Bottoms also was critical of President Donald Trump, saying harsh rhetoric from him is making the situation worse. Cities across the nation, including Atlanta, have been gripped by demonstrations against police violence, and in particular the death of George Floyd, a Minnesota man who died after a police officer used his knee to pin Floyd to the ground by the neck. The officer who pinned Floyd has been charged with third degree murder and manslaughter, and three officers present have been fired. Complete coverage: Atlanta protests “I think that there is a place in America for peaceful protest, and we know that peaceful protests have had a history of changing things in this country,” Bottoms said on CBS’ Face The Nation. “But it has to be organized and it has to be for a purpose. And when you have violent eruptions like we’ve seen across America, then we lose sight of even what we are talking about. Yesterday, all we talked about was how our cities were erupting across America, but we weren’t even talking about George Floyd and so many others who have been killed in this country.” Bottoms said the 9 p.m. curfew in Atlanta and deployment by Gov. Brian Kemp of National Guard forces “helped tremendously” in quelling unrest. Still, protests led to property damage, arrests and some injuries. Atlanta protests: More National Guard troops to deploy ahead of new planned protests in Georgia Bottoms said outside groups were instigators in turning what started Friday as a peaceful demonstration into a violent one. “Obviously, we are the home of the civil rights movement. So, we … have a long history of protest in our city,” Bottoms said. “But our organizers in Atlanta, many of whom don’t agree with me quite often as mayor, were very clear that this, by and large, after things turned violent, was not an Atlanta-based protest. It looked differently racially in our city than our normal protests looked. … So, we don’t know who they were, but many of them were not locally based.” Atlanta police haven’t identified outside groups and The Atlanta Journal-Constitution is seeking more information about those arrested at the protests so far. Bottoms also was asked about comments from Trump in which he told “liberal” mayors and governors to get tougher and threatening to deploy the military. Trump also tweeted the phrase “when the looting starts, the shooting starts,” a reference to comments in the 1960s from a former Florida police chief. Trump also has said he supports peaceful protests, called Floyd’s killing a tragedy and said he stands with Floyd’s family. Asked about Trump making an Oval Office address to the nation, Bottoms said she wants to hear leadership from the president. “What I’d like to hear from the president is leadership,” Bottoms said in an interview on NBC’s Meet The Press. “And I would like to hear a genuine care and concern for our communities and where we are with race relations in America. We know that when he spoke on Charlottesville he made the matter worse. And we’re already — we’re — And we’re well-beyond the tipping point in America. And it’s as my grandmother used to say, ‘If you don’t have anything good to say, sometimes you just shouldn’t say anything at all.’”