ON AIR NOW

LISTEN NOW

Weather

cloudy-day
49°
Clear
H 54° L 33°
  • cloudy-day
    49°
    Current Conditions
    Clear. H 54° L 33°
  • clear-night
    46°
    Evening
    Clear. H 54° L 33°
  • clear-night
    34°
    Morning
    Clear. H 56° L 35°
LISTEN
PAUSE
ERROR

Wsb news on-demand

00:00 | 00:00

LISTEN
PAUSE
ERROR

Wsb traffic on-demand

00:00 | 00:00

LISTEN
PAUSE
ERROR

Wsb weather on-demand

00:00 | 00:00

Local Govt & Politics
Reed pension plan a giveaway to insiders, critics say
Close

Reed pension plan a giveaway to insiders, critics say

Reed pension plan a giveaway to insiders, critics say
Some Atlanta public employees got a deal of a lifetime: pension checks until end of their years. While the offer was extended to 288 employees, only those with high pay could take part. Critics say this was another ploy by former Mayor Reed to reward associates. The city hasn't disclosed the financial impact of the move on a pension fund already short hundreds of millions of dollars.

Reed pension plan a giveaway to insiders, critics say

Editor’s note: A previous version of this story has been corrected to change the hire dates of those eligible for the buy-back program.


Just before former Mayor Kasim Reed left office, the city of Atlanta unveiled a short list of employees who were eligible for the retirement deal of a lifetime: a pension check until the end of their years.

It was a delightful opportunity, especially for high-ranking employees. Those who benefited include City of Atlanta Municipal Court Judge Herman Sloan, Councilwoman Natalyn Archibong, Reed’s former chief of staff Candace Byrd, employee benefits director Louis Amis and Kristen Denius, the attorney in the city’s law department who represented it at pension board meetings, records obtained by the Atlanta Journal-Constitution showed.

Employees who took the deal could come out $100,000 or more ahead compared with what they might have received from the self-directed retirement account offered to them when they were hired, experts told the AJC.

For example, Sloan, whose salary is $182,000 a year, could see a guaranteed pension check in the range of $6,000 to $7,500 a month, if he retires in about five years. Had he stayed in the city’s defined contribution plan – similar to a 401(k) – he may have had a fraction of that, limited by returns on the investments he chose and federal guidelines that cap how much he could sock away each year for retirement.

Close

Reed pension plan a giveaway to insiders, critics say

The pension deal was a farewell gift to Reed’s select employees, critics say, more lucrative than the end-of-year bonuses that the former mayor handed out. And while the 300-some employees eligible for the deal ranged from sanitation workers and customer service representatives, to department heads and top legal staff, only employees with large amounts of disposable cash could afford to take part.

That’s because to join the city pension, employees would have to roll over money from their existing plan and pay all the contributions they would have made had they been in the pension from the time they were hired, along with interest. That was a financial barrier that prevented most employees from opting in. Fewer than 90 of those eligible transferred to the pension.

“This was geared to help people in Kasim Reed’s administration make the most money they could in retirement,’’ said Charles Nash, formerly a member of the City of Atlanta General Employees’ Pension Fund. “These were people (who were) close to retirement, a lot of them are judges, lawyers, the cream of the crop. They did what’s best for them.’’

Pensioners sued the city over the so-called “buy-back” program early this year, alleging it would result in irreparable harm to the pension’s finances.

But in a court filing, the city argued that the program wouldn’t hurt the fund because most of those eligible couldn’t take part. “Only a small fraction of the 288 eligible members are even likely to have sufficient disposable funds to pay the amounts necessary to enroll in the General Employees’ Pension Plan, preventing those who do not from enrolling does not serve any public interest,” the city wrote.

Sloan did not return calls and emails requesting comment about why he switched plans and how it could affect his retirement income.

Reed did not respond to requests for comment.

Archibong, the only eligible council member to make the switch, said she chose to participate because there were no legal or ethical issues that prevented her from doing so.  “I supported the ordinance because of the opportunity for more employees to move into a pension program that would provide ongoing financial certainty for city employees who are retiring,” she wrote in an emailed statement. 

It’s now been months since employees transferred into the city’s pension plan. But the aftershocks are festering among employees and others who say it’s just another example of a back-handed deal in a city hall that is the focus of a major corruption investigation.

“The nepotism and friendships are rampant at city hall,” said Nash, a retired school teacher.

Close

Reed pension plan a giveaway to insiders, critics say


‘Nobody has told me nothing’

Employees hired between July 2001 and July 2005 were automatically placed in the 401(k)-style plan. The city extended eligibility for the new program to employees hired between Jan. 1, 2001 and Dec. 31, 2005.

In 2005, the city provided an opportunity for some of the employees to move into the pension plan.

But when the City Council agreed to the buy-back program in December 2017, Reed’s spokeswoman at the time told the AJC that employees had not been given adequate information about the 2005 offer. Jenna Garland explained that the program would address concerns from the employees about why they weren’t offered the pension plan.

To help employees decide if they wanted to take part this time, the city council also agreed to provide educational materials for affected employees who needed assistance. A council resolution instructed the city finance and human resources departments to provide appropriate education to eligible employees. Archibong, the councilwoman who took the buy-back, was its sponsor.

City officials later said they made every effort to publicize the program so that all eligible employees could take advantage.

Latrecia M. Parks, hired in 2002, was among those eligible. She works as an office assistant in the city’s sanitation department, earning just under $30,000 a year.

With her current salary, she could earn roughly $1,250 a month in retirement, had she joined the pension and worked to normal retirement age. That would be a steady paycheck, no matter what the stock market did.

But she didn’t buy in.

She told the AJC she couldn’t remember anyone contacting her to explain the option.

“Nobody has told me nothing,” Parks said.

Gina Pagnotta-Murphy, a former board member of the General Employees” Pension Fund, said the buy-back opportunity wasn’t widely circulated among general employees, who she said felt “blindsided” by the move. It was clearly fashioned for a select few, she said.

“Nothing went out to all the employees … nothing went out to say, you know you have an opportunity to get in … so we don’t know how that happened,’’ Pagnotta said. “In a perfect world, it should have been left the way it was.”


‘Minimal impact’

It’s not clear how the program will affect finances of the pension system, which already is underfunded by more than $570 million.

The council was advised, in a Nov. 29 report by Segal Consulting, that if the buy back was approved, the pension’s unfunded liability could grow by more than $30 million.

The report warns, though, that the calculations were soft estimates based on various assumptions, and the numbers could not be used for budgeting purposes. One of the assumptions was that there were 281 eligible employees. The council was told in December 2017 that 288 were eligible. But a record the city provided to the AJC listed more more than 300 eligible employees.

The City Council this past June approved the list of those interested in transferring to the pension.

Councilman Howard Shook, who heads the council’s executive finance committee, told the AJC in an email that the finance department had deemed the cost to transfer employees into the fund as “budget-neutral.” Shook, who was eligible for the transfer but did not take it, did not respond to repeated interview requests.

Leon F. “Rocky” Joyner Jr., the actuary who provides financial forecasts for the fund, said in an email response to questions from the AJC that he believed the new entrants would “have minimal impact” on how much the city would have to contribute on behalf of those who joined.

He did not address the question of whether it would add more red ink to the fund. That issue, he said, was still under scrutiny as part of an annual study that provides a snapshot of the pension’s financial health, including an estimate of benefit costs, as well as a real-time update of the pension’s shortfall.

Reed’s critics have said that it was irresponsible to offer the more generous pension benefits without understanding the true impact to the pension system.

When the council voted, city officials didn’t provide a detailed analysis of the impact to the unfunded liability, nor on how much the city would have to contribute on behalf of the newcomers, said Council President Felicia Moore, who voted against the plan in 2017.

“I didn’t support it because I wasn’t so sure we had done enough due diligence on how that would impact the defined benefit plan,’’ Moore told the AJC.

She also said that the timing of the move was noteworthy.

“If all the arguments were true at the time that we had to push everyone new into a defined contribution plan, what made it different was that now we were opening it up, getting to the end of the (Reed) administration,” she said.

Close

Reed pension plan a giveaway to insiders, critics say

The lawsuit filed by the General Employees pension board and joined by the City of Atlanta Police Officers Pension Fund argued that Reed’s plan would harm the fund.

Tony Biello, who served as chairman of the police pension for two decades, told the AJC it was absurd to bring on more liability to a pension system that is already underfunded.

“It’s beyond frivolous,’’ said Biello, who is retired after several decades as a city police officer. “Why would a pension fund want to incur more unfunded liability for people who failed to do their personal responsibility to themselves?”

Ken Allen, a former Atlanta police officer, said the lawsuit was ultimately dropped after the city threatened to individually sue some pension leaders.

In a court filing, the city had alleged that pension funds were being misappropriated to finance the lawsuit, which it contended was filed primarily for the benefit of some individual pension board members.

“It was a strategy the city used to put pressure on people who couldn’t afford the litigation to proceed,” said Allen, who is a regional representative for the National Association of Government Employees, a Massachusetts-based group of federal, state, county and municipal employees across the nation.

The AJC asked Chuck Carr of Southern Actuarial Services, the actuary for the city’s police pension fund, whether the addition of no more than 90 people would affect the General Employees fund’s bottom line. He said the police board also had asked him to evaluate the impact.

He said it was unlikely that the extra employees wouldn’t worsen the shortfall.

“First of all, that defies common sense … how you can add people at the 11th hour and not have any impact?” Carr said.

Ted Siedle, a Florida-based pension consultant who previously addressed the council when Reed wanted to cut pensions, said he was surprised to hear that, as the mayor departed, the city expanded the plan to dozens of employees.

“How can they afford people moving into the pension system?” he said. “It sounds like this is for the gilded few.”

arrow-leftHOW MUCH IS A CITY PENSION WORTH?arrow-left

The city of Atlanta sponsors three defined benefit plans for police, fire and general employees. Each employee who is a member of one of these funds receives a monthly check upon retirement for the rest of their lives. If they are married, a surviving spouse also may benefit.

The monthly check is based on a mathematical calculation based on how many years the employee worked for the city, their average salary over their three consecutive highest-paid years, and a “multiplier,” which is set by the city council.In simplest terms, here’s how it could work:

Suppose you are member of the general employees’ pension. If you retire at age 60 with 25 years of service at an average monthly salary of $2,500, your normal monthly pension benefit would be roughly $1,562.The city manages pension investments, and the income is guaranteed.

Some employees are not in a city pension fund. Instead, they may be covered by a “defined contribution” plan, similar to a 401(k), to which they and the city have contributed. Employees choose investment options. Retirement income will depend on how much has been contributed to the account and how well the investments performed. Some participants will do better than others. No specific retirement income is promised. When the money runs out, it runs out.
Source: Summary Plan Description for the General Employees’ Pension Plan, Police Officer’s Pension Plan, Firefighter’s Pension Plan

 
Read More
VIEW COMMENTS

There are no comments yet. Be the first to post your thoughts. or Register.

News

  • A Houston-area father is charged with child abandonment after police said he left his children alone in a car for more than an hour as he shopped. Police said Adrian Dreshuan Middleton was in the store for an hour and a half before he came out to the car. His daughter was crying in the back seat. She told police that she and her brother were playing, but she was angry that he didn’t stop crying so she wrapped the seatbelt around the baby, The Associated Press reported. She thought he had fallen asleep. But the baby was strangled by the belt, police said. Middleton said he saw his son unconscious with the belt wrapped around him. He called 911 and performed CPR on his son until first responders arrived, KHOU reported. >> Read more trending news  The baby was taken to an area hospital where he was pronounced dead.  Middleton first told police that the children were in their car seats but then said in a different statement to law enforcement that there were no car seats in the car when the incident took place, KHOU reported. Police charged Middleton Friday in the case that happened in May.  According to police records, Middleton told police he left his 6-year-old daughter and 1-year -old son in the car, parked outside a thrift store. He said he left the air conditioner running, a movie playing and gave them water and a snack when he went in to shop for clothes, The AP reported. Middleton turned himself in to police on Monday, KHOU reported.
  • A Tennessee woman was attacked by her husband because she “took too long” getting ready for church, according to a police affidavit. Kevin Pugues, 25, is accused of hitting and strangling his wife at their home on Durango Road in Memphis on Saturday afternoon, the affidavit said. The victim reportedly told police that the pair got into a verbal argument around 2 p.m. Saturday because she was taking “too long dressing herself for church.” >> Read more trending news  Police said the victim blocked her husband’s path to speak with him as he was gathering his items to leave the home. At that point, Pugues shoved her onto the couch and started slapping her on the face, the affidavit said. As she tried to call police, she said Pugues grabbed her neck with both hands and strangled her.  Pugues admitted to police that he struck his wife on the face and strangled her, the affidavit said. He is being charged with aggravated assault.
  • Handcuffs couldn’t stop Jesse Thedford. From the back of a patrol car, the 32-year-old was able to slide behind the wheel of a Carroll County deputy’s car, according to police.  Ignoring commands to stop, Thedford instead drove toward deputies — the same ones who had arrested him after finding methamphetamine in his pocket. One deputy fired a shot, striking and killing Thedford in one of Georgia’s 79 officer-involved shootings through Nov. 15 this year.  The number of shootings involving Georgia law enforcement officers this year will likely pass the number in 2017, and it has also been a deadlier year, according to the GBI. Law officials say drug use is one reason for the increase. One drug in particular has been a factor in nearly 20 percent of the fatal shootings involving officers since 2012: methamphetamine.  “I believe that many of the bizarre and very violent crimes that occur, the perpetrator is a meth user, and that’s from my experience,” GBI Director Vernon Keenan told The Atlanta Journal-Constitution. “It is a very destructive drug, and it causes violent behavior.”  Previously, investigators only had anecdotal evidence of the amount of meth on the streets and the violence it causes, Keenan said. But the GBI recently analyzed its records to get a more factual estimate of the problem. The agency’s autopsy reports, including toxicology results, for people killed by cops, show that meth is involved in about 1 in 5 officer-involved shootings.  The majority of those killed by Georgia police officers from 2012 until mid-November had drugs in their system, including cocaine, meth and marijuana, according to the GBI. Over that period, 188 people were killed by law enforcement and toxicology tests were performed in 173 of those cases. The tests found 124 were positive for a variety of drugs, and 35 — about 19 percent — were positive for meth. Results are still pending on 5 additional cases, including Thedford’s.  Marijuana was the most common drug used by those in deadly altercations with police, followed by methamphetamine, GBI data showed.  And though illegal drugs are just one factor in officer-involved shootings, the data can be used by law enforcement agencies that train officers to de-escalate situations before the use of force is necessary.  “They could be high on methamphetamine,” Keenan said. “And that alone is not going to justify the officer using force, but it is a factor to be considered.”  Meth in Metro Atlanta  The GBI crime lab, which handles drug testing for most of the state’s police departments, sees more than twice as much meth as other drugs. In 2016 and 2017, meth was the leading cause of drug deaths, passing cocaine from previous years, the GBI said.  In Atlanta’s intown neighborhoods, meth isn’t the typical drug of choice, according to police. But travel a few miles into metro suburbs, and it can be found everywhere.  Methamphetamine isn’t new: it has been around nearly 100 years since it was first developed in Japan. During World War II, it was used to keep troops awake and ready for battle, according to the Foundation for a Drug-Free World. Experts now believe it is more common than ever.  Sgt. Josh Liedke, who runs the Marietta police department’s Crime Interdiction Unit, said heroin previously was among the top illegal drugs seized during investigations, but that has changed.  “We’re seeing less seizures of heroin and we’re seeing more seizures of meth,” he said. “We seem to see heroin trickling off a tad. But as soon as we attack one, the other starts creeping up.”  In 2016, the Gwinnett County police department’s special investigations unit seized approximately 262 pounds of meth, worth an estimated $14 million, and arrested 78 people, according to Lt. Eric Wilkerson. The following year, the unit recovered 344 pounds of meth, leading to 68 arrests, he said. The numbers for 2018 are expected to be similar.  It’s not just suburban areas where meth is widespread. It’s also a problem in rural areas, according to law enforcement agencies.  RELATED: Meth is back and killing more people than ever “Meth is the predominant drug right now in north Georgia,” Phil Price, commander of the Cherokee Multi-Agency Narcotics Squad, said. “It’s readily available and it’s commonly used by those in the drug community.”  The active ingredient in meth is pseudoephedrine, found in many over-the-counter cold medications. When combined and heated with other easy-to-find chemicals — which weren’t intended for human consumption — it doesn’t take a scientist to make meth, according to experts.  But chemicals used to make meth are volatile and toxic, leading to explosions for those without chemistry knowledge, according to the U.S. Department of Justice. In addition, the fumes are dangerous for others in the area. Meth can be found in a variety of forms, which can be ingested by swallowing, snorting, smoking, or injecting it.  “There’s so many different ways to make meth, you just don’t know what you’re getting,” Liedke says.  In recent years, meth labs operating in homes and even rolling meth labs in cars frequently made headlines in metro Atlanta.  But more recently, there isn’t a need for users to make their own meth, Keenan said. It’s now being manufactured in Mexico and smuggled into the U.S., and investigators believe that drug cartels are supplying Georgia with meth that’s purer than what is made here — and it’s cheaper.  “It’s like liquor. It’s cheaper to buy it from a Mexican source,” Price said. “At the end of the day, you really don’t have people going out and getting the ingredients to make meth.”    Can officers train for meth?  Keenan, the GBI’s director, said many bizarre and violent crimes that occur involve a meth user. But tracking data, including officer-involved shooting deaths, can help law enforcement agencies better prepare to avoid future violence.  “I think the officer is better prepared to respond when they have an understanding of what they’re up against,” Keenan said.  Like others in the metro area, Marietta officers attend a week of crisis intervention training as part of their ongoing education. The crisis training focuses on both mental health and drugs, including how to identify warning signs that someone is under the influence of drugs. Officers learn de-escalation techniques to calm people: ways to hopefully stop a situation without violence. Whether someone is having a mental health breakdown or has been using alcohol or drugs, the tactics are similar, officers said.  “It may be a different substance, but the way you deal with it is the same across the board,” Price said.  But the effects of a meth on a person’s demeanor is completely unpredictable and creates a particular challenge for officers. Violence and paranoia are common among users.  “These people are physically aggressive and paranoid, and they’ll perceive things that aren’t reality,” Price said.  Meth users also may be desensitized to pain, Price said, so using a Taser may not affect them. If other tactics don’t work, officers may have to use their weapons.  Despite the emphasis of the Trump administration on the opioid crisis, Keenan calls meth an “international assault on the U.S.” And he sees no signs that meth use is slowing down.  “We traded one evil for another,” he said. “Fire and explosions and toxic chemicals for ultra-pure methamphetamine.”  Investigators may not be able to keep the dangerous drug out of their communities. But local, state and federal law enforcement officers aren’t giving up. Every drug bust gets the dangerous drug out of more people’s hands.  In August, after a nearly year-long investigation, the U.S. Drug Enforcement Administration — along with metro Atlanta agencies and the Georgia State Patrol — busted up a major drug ring. More than $5 million worth of cocaine, and 250 pounds of methamphetamine along with $850,000 in cash was recovered and 15 people were arrested.  DEA Atlanta agent Robert J. Murphy said the drug bust involved one of several Mexican cartels operating in Atlanta.  “Another successful law enforcement success targeting the Mexican organizations targeting this poison in our community,” Murphy said. MORE ON METH  • Methamphetamine is usually a white, bitter-tasting powder or a pill. Crystal methamphetamine looks like glass fragments or shiny, bluish-white rocks  • Methamphetamine is a stimulant drug that is chemically similar to amphetamine, a drug used to treat ADHD and narcolepsy  • People can take methamphetamine by smoking, swallowing, snorting, or injecting it  • Short-term health effects include increased wakefulness and physical activity, decreased appetite, and increased blood pressure and body temperature  • Long-term health effects include risk of contracting HIV and hepatitis; severe dental problems; intense itching, leading to skin sores from scratching; violent behavior; and paranoia.  • Methamphetamine is highly addictive. When people stop using it, withdrawal symptoms can include anxiety, fatigue, severe depression, psychosis, and intense drug cravings.  • The most effective treatments for methamphetamine addiction so far are behavioral therapies. There are currently no government-approved medications to treat meth addiction.  Source: National Institute on Drug Abuse
  • It's that time again. President Donald Trump and first lady Melania Trump will host the annual presidential turkey pardoning ceremony Tuesday afternoon in the White House Rose Garden, where one lucky bird will be named the National Thanksgiving Turkey.  >> Which restaurants are open on Thanksgiving? Here’s a list The pardoning, set for 1:05 p.m. EST, has been an annual tradition since 1989, but Thanksgiving turkeys have been presented to presidents for seven decades, The Associated Press reported. >> Read more trending news  This year, Peas and Carrots, two turkeys from South Dakota, are vying for the honor. Peas, a 39-pounder with a 36-inch wing span, loves Brad Paisley and popcorn, while the 41-pound Carrots enjoys yoga and boasts a 'strong and confident' gobble, the White House joked on its website. >> See their stats here In true reality show fashion, you can vote for your favorite gobbler on the White House website or on Twitter. >> See the poll here After the ceremony, Peas and Carrots will live at Gobbler's Rest at Virginia Tech in Blacksburg, Virginia. Read more here. – The Associated Press contributed to this report.
  • A DeKalb County woman said her mega bank made a mega mistake and now nearly $9,000 of her money is missing. Roslyn Baitney said her money went through the tube at Wells Fargo and then disappeared. She blames the bank for what happened next. Baitney said 10 days ago she put $8,754 into the drive-thru tube to deposit with a teller at the bank on Flat Shoals Parkway.  Baitney said the teller told her that the deposit was too large and that she would need to go inside. Baitney said the teller never told her that she was going to send the tube back. >> Read more trending news  The incident report which said the teller alerted Baitney she was sending her money back through the tube. There was no money when she got inside. “I tapped on the window and said, ‘Hey, where's my money?’” Baitney said. A car had been in line behind her at the drive-thru.  “And then the teller said, ‘I wondered why the car behind you never did a transaction. They just pulled off.’ ‘Yeah, because you gave them my money,’” Baitney said. The police report also indicates security video was recorded off site, the bank won't talk about the video. The money is not the only worry for Baitney. “But I'm an open book because my identity is out there. My drivers license, my bank card, my bank info. It was all inside of that tube,” Baitney said. Baitney fears a thief now knows where she lives. She's been staying with her fiancé. “I don't like throwing people under the bus but there was a mistake made and the bank made the mistake,” Baitney said. A Wells Fargo spokesman emailed: We are aware of the issue at the Chapel Square branch and are working to resolve it.” The spokesman refused further comment due to an on-going criminal investigation “That's my house note, my car note, my car insurance. What are you all going to do?” Baitney said. A Wells Fargo official in Birmingham has called Baitney to say she'd have her money in full by midday Tuesday.
  • A kindergarten student was burned so badly by food at a Tennessee school that she had to be treated at a local hospital, according to a lawsuit filed in Shelby County. >> Watch the news report here The lawsuit, which is filed on behalf of the girl by her mother, names Shelby County Schools as the defendant. The alleged incident happened on Oct. 23 at Double Tree Elementary School in Memphis. The child was getting lunch – mashed potatoes – at the on-site cafeteria. >> Read more trending news  After getting her food, she was walking toward a table when she slipped on a wet spot on the cafeteria floor. The hot food landed on her arm and “resulted in severe burns … that required medical treatment,” according to the lawsuit. The lawsuit claims the kindergartner did not know the mashed potatoes were that hot – and she did not see the wet spot on the floor. It claims Shelby County Schools is liable for the incident and that every aspect could have been prevented. The family is seeking compensation for damages that include: Physical pain and suffering Emotional pain and suffering Medical bills and expenses Permanent disfigurement Loss of enjoyment of life Post-judgement interest Statutory and discretionary costs And all such further relief to which she may be entitled WHBQ reached out to SCS regarding the lawsuit, and officials said they cannot comment on 'pending lawsuits.' WHBQ’s Greg Coy spoke with the family’s attorney. 'A child should not suffer second-degree burns at a school,' said attorney Thomas Greer of Bailey and Greer Law Firm. 'I don't think anybody would expect a burn like to happen. It’s just something that should not happen. 'Our kids should not be burned with the food that has been served.' Greer told WHBQ that the girl has returned to school, but she brings her lunch now and avoids the cafeteria line.