On Air Now

Listen Now

Weather

cloudy-day
53°
Cloudy
H -° L 51°
  • cloudy-day
    53°
    Current Conditions
    Cloudy. H -° L 51°
  • cloudy-day
    Today
    Cloudy. H -° L 51°
  • rain-day
    64°
    Tomorrow
    Rain. H 64° L 50°
Listen
Pause
Error

News on-demand

00:00 | 00:00

Listen
Pause
Error

Traffic on-demand

00:00 | 00:00

Listen
Pause
Error

Weather on-demand

00:00 | 00:00

National Govt & Politics
Digging into the release of the Carter Page FISA application
Close

Digging into the release of the Carter Page FISA application

Digging into the release of the Carter Page FISA application
Photo Credit: Jamie Dupree

Digging into the release of the Carter Page FISA application

President Donald Trump on Sunday accused the FBI and Justice Department of misleading a special intelligence court, as both parties wrestled over the details of surveillance requests made in 2016 and 2017 on a one-time Trump Campaign aide, Carter Page, in which the FBI made the case that "Page has been collaborating and conspiring with the Russian Government."

"Witch Hunt Rigged, a Scam!" the President tweeted from his New Jersey golf club, as he again denounced the investigation into Russian interference of the 2016 elections, and any possible ties to the Trump Campaign.

What exactly do the details show? Let's take an extended look.

1. First, this is a historic move by the FBI. This was the first time that the FBI had ever released details about a surveillance warrant requests under the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act, which are made to a special, secret intelligence court. The release was spearheaded by a lawsuit filed in part by Brad Heath, an investigative reporter with USA Today. As one might expect, much of the document is redacted because of intelligence and investigative reasons, keeping many people guessing about what was actually in the 412 pages released to the public, which you can read for yourself.

2. FBI request came after Page left Trump Campaign. After stories had surfaced in September of 2016 raising questions about Carter Page's ties to certain Russian interests, Page had left his role as a foreign policy adviser to the Trump Campaign. The FBI did not ask for a surveillance warrant until October of 2016, after Page was already out of his role. That undermines the President's complaint on Sunday which he aired on Twitter: "Looking more & more like the Trump Campaign for President was illegally being spied upon (surveillance) for the political gain of Crooked Hillary Clinton and the DNC," the President wrote. But the facts when it comes to the timing of the case don't bear that out.

3. What did the FBI base its request on? Here we start getting into the meat of the political debate on the Page FISA warrant. The FBI was pretty blunt about what it believed was happening when it came to Russian interference in the 2016 elections: "the FBI believes that the Russian Government's efforts are being coordinated with Page and perhaps other individuals associated with Candidate #1's campaign," the FBI wrote in the original surveillance warrant request. One redacted section sets out "Clandestine Intelligence Activities of the Russian Federation," before even getting to details about Page. "The FBI believes Page has been the subject of targeted recruitment by the Russian Government," the FISA request states. One name that makes an appearance early on in the FBI request is that of George Papadopoulos, who has already plead guilty to lying to the FBI about contacts with Russians.

4. Zeroing in on the Page FISA request. The FBI sets out that "Page has established relationships with Russian Government officials, including Russian intelligence officers" - and then a redacted session of evidence. The document recounts how two Russian intelligence agents tried to recruit Page in 2015 during meetings in New York. Finally after 15 pages, the FBI gets to a 'confidential human source (Source #1) - that would be the former British Intelligence agent Christopher Steele, who authored what's become known as the Steele Dossier, assembled by the company Fusion GPS, and paid for by interests supporting Hillary Clinton's campaign.

5. The FBI addresses the Steele Dossier. Here is where the two parties will go different ways on what was included in the FBI surveillance request on Carter Page, as it pertains to Steele. In the GOP memo released earlier this year by House Intelligence Chairman Rep. Devin Nunes (R-CA), Republicans accused the FBI of not giving the FISC court any information about who was bankrolling the information from Steele - but the document clearly says that a "U.S.-based law firm had hired the identified U.S. person to conduct research regarding Candidate #1's ties to Russia," and the FBI makes clear what they thought it was for: "The FBI speculates that the identified U.S. person was likely looking for information that could be used to discredit Candidate #1's campaign." Even with that knowledge, "the FBI believes Source #1's reporting herein to be credible."

6. The FBI document undermines Nunes on one point. In the GOP memo released back in February about this FISA request, Republicans state clearly that the "Carter Page FISA application also cited extensively a September 23, 2016 Yahoo News article by Michael Isikoff," making it seem like the FBI was relying on information in that article to support the FBI request for surveillance of Page. Except when you read the actual FISA document, that article is noted under a section headlined, "Page's Denial of Cooperation with the Russian Government," as the FBI even includes information from a letter that Page wrote to the FBI Director denying any wrongdoing. The GOP memo is first in the below graphic, followed by the FISA warrant request.

8. The FBI's bottom line in October 2016. The FBI wraps up its request with a succinct accusation - "the FBI believes that Page has been collaborating and conspiring with the Russian Government."

9. This is really four surveillance applications. While the document begins with the FBI's initial request for 90 days of surveillance on Carter Page from October of 2016, the 412 pages also include a renewal request from January of 2017, another renewal in April 2017, and a final renewal of the FISA warrant on Page in June of 2017. Each time, the information supporting the request for surveillance increased in length, suggesting that the FBI was including actual intelligence information gleaned from the investigation of Page, and why it supported further monitoring by U.S law enforcement. We don't get to read any of that, because in those sections, it is page after page of blacked-out materials, making it difficult for us to evaluate what was presented by the FBI, and how the rulings were made by the intelligence court.

10. The four judges involved were appointed by Republicans. For the first time, we learned the identities of the judges on the special Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Court who dealt with the four requests for surveillance on Carter Page - and it turns out that all four were put on the federal bench by Republican Presidents - Reagan, the first President Bush, and President George W. Bush. In a tweet, the President quoted Andrew McCarthy, a legal analyst who often appears on Fox News: "This is so bad that they should be looking at the judges who signed off on this stuff, not just the people who gave it."

 

Read More

News

  • A Texas woman snapped a photograph of a rare sight -- a pink grasshopper that her son found in her garden. Alison Barger told KXAN the grasshopper was spotted by her 3-year-old son, Brooks. According to Victoria Hillman of National Geographic, the rare species is a genetic mutation. “We believe these funky individuals to be a rare morph of the common meadow grasshopper,” Hillman wrote in a blog for the magazine. Hillman said the mutation is called erythrism, and it’s caused by a recessive gene similar to the one that affects albino animals, KXAN reported. “This mutation results in one of two things happening or even a combination of the two; a reduce or even absence of the normal pigment and/or the excessive production of other pigments,” Hillman wrote in the National Geographic blog.
  • Golfing legend Mickey Wright, a Hall of Famer who won 82 LPGA titles and 13 championships during her career, died Monday of a heart attack, her attorney said. She was 85. Wright’s attorney, Sonia Pawluc, told The Associated Press that Wright had been hospitalized for the last few weeks after suffering injuries in a fall. The LPGA confirmed the news of Wright’s death. Born in San Diego, Mary Kathryn Wright maintained a private life after retiring from golf and moved to Port St. Lucie, Florida, in 1974, where she spent the final years of her life, TCPalm reported. “We are deeply saddened to learn about the passing of Mickey Wright,” LPGA Commissioner Michael Whan said in a statement. “We lost a legend, but we may also have lost the best swing in golf history today. Our thoughts are with her family and friends.” Wright’s smooth golf swing was envied by golfers worldwide. She learned her swing when she was 15 from California golf instructor Harry Pressler, traveling 250 miles round trip every Saturday for two years, Golfweek reported. “She had the finest golf swing I ever saw,” PGA legend Ben Hogan said. Wright broke into the LPGA in 1955. According to her LPGA biography, Wright is the only player in LPGA history to hold all four major titles at the same time. She captured the U.S. Women’s Open -- an event she would win four times -- and the LPGA Championship in 1961 and completed the Grand Slam run by winning the first two majors of 1962, the Titleholders Championship and the Western Open. Wright won 44 times in a four-year run (1961-64), according to the Golf Channel. In 1963-64, Wright served as the LPGA’s president and was voted Associated Press Woman Athlete of the Year. She was inducted into the Hall of Fame of Women’s Golf in 1964, the LPGA Tour Hall of Fame when it was created in 1967 and the World Golf Hall of Fame in 1976, according to the LPGA. “At my best I would go into what I called a ‘fog.’ I never thought of it as the ‘zone’ you hear about today, though maybe it was something like that,” Wright told Golf Digest in a 2017 interview. “It was a mental state where I could concentrate really well and play with a greater confidence than usual. I had it when I shot 62 at Hunting Creek in Louisville in 1964. It was elusive, but that’s when I played my best.” Wright retired as an active player in 1969, when she was 34. She won $368,770 during her career, according to the LPGA. Wright was named Female Golfer of the Century by The Associated Press in 2000. Kathy Whitworth, who holds the LPGA’s all-time record with 88 career wins, said Wright was the best player she’d ever seen, Golfweek reported. “The PGA of America is deeply saddened by the passing of Mickey Wright, who will forever be one of the greatest to play our game. Her swing put the greats in awe & we are forever thankful for her efforts to advance women’s golf.” PGA President Suzy Whaley said in a statement. “There’s got to be golf in heaven,” Wright told Golf Digest in 2017. “I hope I get there and that it’s just me and my 2-iron. Or maybe a couple of angels will be looking on. Everything will look like Sea Island Golf Club did in the old days, sedate and beautiful. I’ll be facing that shot to a well-trapped green again, trying to duplicate that shot from 1957. If it’s really heaven, I’ll pull it off.”
  • Trying to feed a newborn in the middle of the night can be stressful. Not having any milk or formula complicates matters. That is why a Utah mother of five called 911 last month when she was out of formula and mother’s milk, KSL reported. “I’ve never not had food for my newborn,” Shannon Bird told the television station about her 2:12 a.m. call Jan. 28. “It was really scary for me.” In a recording of the 911 call, Bird told the dispatcher she had no way to feed her s6-week-old baby, KSL reported. “I’ve been calling neighbors and no one will answer,” Bird told the dispatcher. “I’ve never been in this predicament ever. My milk just literally dried out. This is my fifth kid and this has never happened.” Bird said her husband was out of town and her other children were asleep, the television station reported. “She (baby) was screaming,” Bird told KSL. “I called my husband and we were brainstorming. I started calling neighbors and teenagers in the area and my little brother and no one was awake.” Officers from the Lone Peak Police Department came to the rescue, as officer Brett Wagstaff went to a convenience store and bought a gallon of milk, the television station reported. However, the infant was too young for regular milk, so Wagstaff had to make another trip. “We’ll leave this with you,” Wagstaff is heard saying on body-camera footage, KSL reported. as he handed Bird the milk. “We’ll be right back with some formula for your baby — she’s adorable.” Wagstaff and fellow officer Konner Gabbitas went to a nearby Walmart, bought some formula and refused Bird’s offer to pay them back, the television station reported. “I was not expecting them to go get that food for me,” Bird told KSL. Dave Ventrano, Lone Peak Police Department’s public information officer, praised the two officers. “Most of us, we got on this job to help people, and this was an example of helping out a mother that was in need,” Ventrano told KSL. “To this mom, this is a priority for her. It’s been about protect and serve. This is part of the serve. We are here to serve the public.”
  • Crime is still not paying off for an Indiana man. Donald Murray, 38, of Terre Haute, who sports a “Crime Pays” tattoo on his forehead, was arrested for the second time in three months after he led police on a chase Monday morning, WTWO reported. In December, Murray was arrested when he allegedly led police in Terre Haute on a high-speed chase, the Tribune-Star reported. Police said Murray was driving at night with his headlights off, WTHI reported. The incident was caught on the television show “Live PD” and went viral. On Monday, Terre Haute police said Murray was charged with resisting law enforcement, reckless driving, possession of methamphetamine, maintaining a common nuisance and auto theft, WTWO reported. Murray was released on his own recognizance Jan. 14 for his December arrest, the television station reported.
  • State and local police in Massachusetts are searching for vandals who defaced several historic landmarks in Plymouth overnight, including Plymouth Rock. The Maiden Lady and the National Monument to the Forefathers were just some of the other sites targeted with red spray paint. The graffiti was discovered Monday morning and was quickly reported to the police, WFXT reported. Plymouth Rock marks where the Pilgrims landed the Mayflower 400 years ago. The date, 1620, is chiseled into the rock. Crews with the State Department of Conservation and Recreation and Plymouth’s own Parks Department used a special solution with paint remover to power wash the graffiti off the landmarks. Those crews also got some help from volunteers. Jake Mowles, who owns East Coast Powerwashing, got busy cleaning one of the monuments free of charge. “We were pretty upset about it, we’ve spent a lot of money this year or the town has spent a lot of money rehabilitating the whole town here and it’s pretty disgraceful for somebody to do this,” Mowles told WFXT. “If we have the resources to do it and can come out and take care of it for them, that’s why we’re doing it.” Plymouth’s park superintendent said it will likely take several days to clean up all of the graffiti.
  • Jason Davis, a voice actor on the Disney cartoon series 'Recess,” died Sunday in Los Angeles, his manager said. He was 35. The cause of the actor’s death is not yet known, CNN reported. “We’re very saddened by his loss and we had some great projects in the works and really sad to see someone pass away at such a young age and taken out of his prime,” Scotty Gelt, President of Wolfie Cohen Entertainment, Davis’s management company, told CNN in a statement. “We’re just praying for him and hope he’s in a happier place.” Davis was the grandson of philanthropist Barbara Davis and late studio head Marvin Davis, according to The Hollywood Reporter. He was the son of Nebil Zarif and Nancy Davis Rickel. “Jason had a true heart of gold with such a zest for life,” Rickel told The Hollywood Reporter in a statement. “He was such a caring soul to everybody who ever knew him.” Jason Davis appeared in 129 episodes of “Recess” from 1997 to 2001 as the character of Mikey Blumberg, according to IMDB.com. He also appeared on television shows, including “Roseanne” (where he played an obnoxious vampire kid) and three episodes of “7th Heaven” in 1997, according to E Online. In addition to acting on TV, Davis had several battles with substance abuse and discussed them on “Celebrity Rehab With Dr. Drew” in 2010 and 2011, according to The Hollywood Reporter. He co-founded the charity Cure Addiction Now. Davis was working on a television show called “The Two Jasons” at the time of his death, according to The Hollywood Reporter.