Follow us on

Listen live to Atlanta's breaking news, severe weather, & traffic online

recent on-air advertisers

Now Playing

News/Talk WSB
Listen live to ...

Kirk Mellish's Weather Commentary

Posted: 10:35 a.m. Thursday, Feb. 4, 2010

Hail hail the severe threat is downsized 

By Kirk Mellish

Hail size comparison.

Hail size comparison.
NOAA/NWS

If you step outside in a thunderstorm and get bonked on the head with penny size hail, don't blame your misfortune on a severe storm. On January 5, the National Weather Service changed the criteria for severe thunderstorms by upping the minimum size hail from ¾ to 1 inch--quarter size. The wind threshold--50 knots, or 58 mph--remains the same.

The reason for the change, according to a statement issued by the Fire and Public Weather Services Branch of the NWS, is that research reveals "significant damage" doesn't occur from hail smaller than an inch. Hailstones the size of quarters or larger are the ones most destructive to cars, homes, buildings, and crops.

Frankly this is long overdue and something I've been lobbying in favor of for years. The same thing needs to be done for winds. The severe wind criteria is too easily reached and 60 mph wind gusts are too common in strong storms especially in certain parts of the country like Georgia.  Whatever did our parents and grandparents do without so many warnings?  How did they survive?  How did we as kids?  There is thunder and lightning and rain and wind. You shouldn't need a "significant weather alert" or warning to tell you to get in out of the rain especially when there is lightning. Lightning alone makes ALL thunderstorms potentially damaging or fatal therefore dangerous or severe. The only "safety action" to take is the one dictated by common sense. Get inside. Presumably anyone with a brain will get inside when lightning flashes and thunder roars without waiting for an "official warning". 60-mph winds will only cause minor inconvenience "damage" a few shingles or some outdoor furniture blown around or weak tree limbs falling. Too many "severe" thunderstorm warnings have made them a meaningless routine of spring and summer.


Over the years, and particularly in the Plains states, the statement reads, "the frequency of severe thunderstorm warnings issued for penny-size and nickel-size hail might have desensitized the public to take protective action during a severe thunderstorm warning." Too many warnings for events that were not damaging garnered complaints and made the warnings somewhat meaningless.


Experimental warnings for 1-inch hail in Kansas the last few years expanded in the central and western United States in 2009. Emergency managers and media outlets in the areas that previously made the changes noted that people seem to take warnings for severe hail more seriously now as they carry more weight.

Of course observing hailstones 1 inch or larger and forecasting hail size are two different things. But, just as research has supported increasing the severe hail threshold, scientists are making strides toward more accurately predicting hail size from radar observations of severe thunderstorms. A poster that will be presented by Matthew Kramar of the NWS office in the Washington, D.C. area, et al., on Wednesday afternoon at the Annual Meeting (January 20, 2:30-4:00 PM, Exhibit Hall B2) reveals results of correlating radar hail cores to hail size for the Mid-Atlantic region--a study that piggybacks on successes in establishing operational hail prediction in the Plains states.