H 65° L 46°
  • cloudy-day
    Current Conditions
    Clear. H 65° L 46°
  • clear-day
    Clear. H 65° L 46°
  • cloudy-day
    Partly Cloudy. H 69° L 42°

Wsb news on-demand

00:00 | 00:00


Wsb traffic on-demand

00:00 | 00:00


Wsb weather on-demand

00:00 | 00:00

Tax plan stirs clash of titans

Tax plan stirs clash of titans

Tax plan stirs clash of titans
Photo Credit: Chris Stewart
Chris Hanes, sales manager at P&R Communications Service, is seen with a new digital two-way radio used by the public safety sector. P&R representatives are in favor of the Marketplace Fairness Act that would require retailers to collect sales tax on online sales. CHRIS STEWART / STAFF

Tax plan stirs clash of titans

An online sales-tax proposal has triggered a divisive debate among business owners and attracted a strange-bedfellows mix of supporters that includes the Dayton Area Chamber of Commerce and Democratic U.S. Sen. Sherrod Brown.

The “Marketplace Fairness Act,” which will be voted on by the U.S. Senate as early as Monday, would require Internet retailers with more than $1 million in out-of-state sales to collect sales tax on purchases made online.

Proponents say the legislation will eliminate an unfair advantage that online retailers currently enjoy over bricks and mortar shops, thereby leveling the playing field and saving Ohio-based jobs.

Opponents say it would stifle competition and add an unfair burden on Internet retailers by forcing them to become revenue collectors for 9,600 sales-tax jurisdictions in America — each with its own set of rules and filing requirements. And they say legislators who support the legislation are voting for a tax increase.

A true battle of titans has emerged with retailers’ groups, small-business owners, Walmart and Amazon.com squaring off against the likes of eBay, a collection of small businesses called Web-Enabled Retailers Helping Expand Retail Employment and anti-tax groups such as Americans for Prosperity and Americans for Tax Reform.

The stakes are high. The National Council of State Legislatures estimates that in 2012 alone, states lost out on a collective $23 billion because they were not able to collect sales tax revenue on remote sales. Ohio’s portion of that bounty exceeded $628 million. And a 2011 study by the University of Cincinnati found that the loss of taxes from Internet sales cost the state of Ohio about 11,000 direct jobs that year.

Depending on who you listen to, the law is either a long-overdue measure to equalize competition to better reflect the buying habits of the modern consumer, or an attempt to stifle commerce and penalize states like Oregon and New Hampshire that do not currently have a sales tax.

Current law

For now, states can require stores to collect sales taxes only if the store is physically located in that state. The Marketplace Fairness Act would give states the additional authority to collect sales taxes on Internet purchases, although businesses with less than $1 million a year in sales (and thus the small eBay seller) would be exempt.

Sales taxes would go to the state where the shopper lives, meaning a shopper in Ohio who buys from an online retailer in Michigan would see their sales tax go to Ohio.

Many states — including Ohio — have laws requiring shoppers to pay sales taxes regardless of whether they bought the item in a store or online. But that requirement has never really been enforced and Gordon Gough, executive vice president and CFO for the Ohio Council of Retail Merchants, said fewer than 1 percent of the population actually abides by that rule.

“It would be impossible (to know),” he said. “Unless you go through everyone’s credit card statements.”

In three procedural votes leading up to this week’s scheduled up-or-down vote, the legislation has received support from about two-thirds of the members of the U.S. Senate, including both Ohio senators. But Caitlin Dunn, a spokesman for Sen. Rob Portman, said the Ohio Republican is still examining the bill’s impact and has not decided how he will vote on the final version. Portman, she said, “will not support policies that excessively burden businesses and consumers.”

Most experts expect the bill will easily pass the Senate, but its fate in the GOP-led U.S. House of Representatives is less certain. If it does pass there, however, it will likely become law since President Barack Obama has already indicated his support.

In Ohio, House Republicans recently added language to the state budget bill that positions Ohio to collect the tax should Congress pass the Marketplace Fairness Act.

Business vs. Business

The issue has meant business owners who usually see eye to eye on political and economic matters are on opposite sides of the fence.

Matt Howitt — vice president of Next Lift Inc., a Moraine company that sells, services and rents forklifts and other material-handling equipment — strongly opposes the legislation because he says it will burden small companies such as his. Howitt said he does about 90 percent of his business on the Internet.

“The economy is still struggling as it is,” Howitt said. “Now they’re trying to turn small businesses into revenue enforcers and tax collectors.”

Next Lift ships products “all over the country every day” that have been purchased online, Howitt said. And the company’s employees don’t have the time or resources to fill out tax forms for the 9,600 tax jurisdictions in the U.S. “That doesn’t help create jobs,” Howitt said. “It stops jobs.”

But Nikki Hanes, general manager of P & R Communications Service in downtown Dayton, supports the tax plan because she says the current system penalizes companies like hers. P & R Communications sells two-way radio and wireless broadband equipment and, like other bricks-and-mortar retail stores, charges sales tax on its commercial sales. That gives Hanes’ online competitors an immediate 6 to 7 percent advantage in pricing, she said.

“We have enough competition on margins alone,” Hanes said. “I would like to see an even playing field for all of us when it comes to sales taxes.”

John Marshall, vice president of retail operations for Grismer Tire Company, said he has frequently encountered customers who come into one of Grismer’s 24 stores in the Dayton, Springfield, Fairfield and Columbus areas, price the tires his company sells, then head out to buy the same product online. They do this, he said, to avoid paying sales tax.

“It’s put us at a decided competitive disadvantage,” said Marshall, “People are telling us flat-out that they’re going to end up buying (a product) and having it shipped in because they could save on sales tax.”

In the end, the fate of the bill will likely depend on which business group best sells their narrative of fairness.

Norman Singleton of the Campaign for Liberty, which opposes the Senate bill, said the measure would cause online retailers to raise prices twice — once to add the taxes, and again for compliance costs. While a provision in the bill would allow businesses to receive free software to handle different state tax rates, Singleton questions whether the cost of providing such software and the hassle of using it might be an onerous burden.

“It’s certainly going to raise taxes, raise costs and raise the cost of doing business online,” Singleton said.

Read More

There are no comments yet. Be the first to post your thoughts. or Register.


  • Two children were killed in an accident involving a police SUV in Los Angeles on Thursday night. The Los Angeles County Sheriff's Department vehicle was rushing to the scene of a gunshot victim at 7:25 p.m. PT when it struck five pedestrians in the Boyle Heights section of the city, according to police. In addition to the two killed, three other pedestrians were injured, and two sheriff's deputies in the vehicle were taken to the hospital, according to authorities. The deputies were treated and released Thursday night. The extent of the injuries to the other three pedestrians was unknown.  TRENDING STORIES: Judge grabs flagpole to defend himself as suspect tries to escape courtroom Lawsuit: Sun Dial restaurant ‘had no protections’ to stop 5-year-old’s death $500K worth of items stolen from jewelers' car after convention  Police did not provide the ages of those killed, but said both were minors. 'I was inside in my home and I heard the crash. Within seconds, I was outside and just a few feet from the incident,' eyewitness Paulette de la Cruz told Los Angeles ABC station KABC. 'When I got there I saw a little boy with a white blanket over him. Another one across, I'm not sure if he was conscious or not, but it didn't look like he was.' There were two other vehicles involved in the accident, but no one in the cars were injured. Police said an investigation into the accident was ongoing.  
  • A Georgia seventh-grader had quite the statement planned for his field trip to CNN, but his school ruined it all. >> Read more trending news Jaxon Jester, son of elected local officials Nancy and Stan Jester, donned a shirt that mocked CNN’s logo as “FNN,” standing for “Fake News Network,” on the morning of his school’s trip to visit the network’s Atlanta headquarters. However, a teacher at his school asked him to remove the shirt before the trip even began and now his parents are livid, saying the school violated his First Amendment right to free speech. “This year when the CNN tour was announced, my seventh grade son Jaxon asked me if he could purchase an FNN-Fake News Network shirt to wear for his field trip. As an advocate for the First Amendment, I agreed to his request,” Stan Jester wrote in a blog post about the incident. “His mother cautioned him that he might cause a controversy and needed to be prepared for that. He was fully aware of the implications of his decision and made the affirmative choice to wear his shirt.” The parents reportedly received a phone call from the school’s principal on the morning of the trip, notifying them that their son had been instructed to change his shirt. The Jesters were “disappointed by the hypocrisy” in the school’s decision. “Some students are celebrated when they make a controversial display during the National Anthem,” the boy’s father continued, pointing out that the school previously issued a statement in defense of students who kneeled for the national anthem on the basis of the First Amendment. “My student was forced to remove his shirt because someone didn’t like it. I defend speech and expression, even if I disagree, or it makes me uncomfortable.” In the comments section, Nancy Jester gave readers an update on what happened after the field trip: “After the class was back from the field trip, the principal and the teacher involved called me. The teacher involved said that she told Jax to change his shirt because she thought his shirt said ‘F-CNN.’ I told her that it absolutely did NOT say that. She apologized and said that she now realizes that the shirt has no profanity or suggestion of profanity on it. The principal stated that he should have been made aware of the situation before Jax was made to change his shirt. He apologized for the incident. We discussed how the shirt could have provided valuable learning opportunities if Jax and his fellow students could have explored how we get news and how we process it. The teacher agreed. “Once home Jax described the situation a little differently. He stated that after he boarded the bus for the trip, the teacher came onto his bus and called his name to come forward. He did so. He felt that he was spoken to in a harsh tone and told he must change. He was respectful and complied. He was very upset but kept that to himself.” While the Jesters are displeased with their son’s school’s decision, others have argued that it wasn’t appropriate for the county commissioner and school board member to send their child off to school wearing the shirt in the first place.
  • If you're looking for a shooting star so you can make your wish come true, this weekend may just be your lucky opportunity. The Leonid meteor shower will peak this weekend, providing ideal viewing conditions for millions across the United States. With clear skies predicted by meteorologists in many parts of the country, even amateur stargazers should be able to catch a glimpse of the cosmic spectacle. >> Read more trending news Experts say 10 to 25 shooting stars will be visible per hour in areas with clear skies this Friday evening and Saturday morning, according to the Smithsonian. Even for the unlucky, such a high number gives anyone decent odds of sighting one of the meteors. For those hoping to view the shower this weekend, here's everything you need to know: What is the Leonid meteor shower? The Leonid meteors are connected to the comet Tempel-Tuttle, according to David Samuhel, senior meteorologist and astronomy blogger at AccuWeather. 'It makes fairly frequent passes through the inner solar system,' he said. 'This lays out fresh debris in the path of the Earth's orbit every 33 years.' The Earth actually passes through the debris of the comet, making the falling particles visible as they burn up in the atmosphere. Thanks to clear skies and the absence of moonlight, this year's display should give stargazers a decent show. Where will the meteor shower be most visible? First of all, stargazers should get as far away from city lights as possible to avoid light pollution. There's no specific spot in the sky to look. But the shooting stars get their name from the Leo constellation, as their paths in the sky can be traced back to those stars. Peak time for viewing is from 2 a.m. to 4 a.m. ET Saturday. People living throughout the Southeast, the Northern Plains and California are in luck, as meteorologists are predicting clear skies, ideal for viewing the shower. Those who reside in the Northeast, the Great Lakes region, the central Plains or the Pacific Northwest, however, may have to travel to other areas if they want to spot a falling star. 'A large storm system will be moving from the Plains into the Great Lakes, and cloudy skies are forecast to dominate much of the eastern half of the nation,' meteorologist Kyle Elliot said, according to Accuweather. 'Rain and thunderstorms will put an even bigger damper on viewing conditions in many of these areas.' The shower will actually be most visible, with the highest rates of visible meteors, in East Asia. How intense can a Leonid shower get? While this weekend's display is sure to impress, it's actually considered a light meteor shower, as opposed to a meteor storm. The last Leonid meteor storm took place in 2002. During storms, thousands of meteors can be spotted in an hour. In 1833, stargazers reported as many as 72,000 shooting stars per hour, according to National Geographic. In 1966, a group of hunters reported seeing 40 to 50 streaks per second over the duration of 15 minutes. Scientists currently predict the next major outburst won't take place until 2099. But calculations suggest the comet will be returning closer to Earth in 2031 and 2064, meaning more intense storms may be seen sooner. Smaller showers, such as the one occurring this weekend, happen on a regular basis. So, while you may get another shot at seeing Leonid's shooting stars, this weekend promises to be a great chance for many.
  • We’re just days away from the implosion of the Georgia Dome! Channel 2’s Nicole Carr went to Vine City where some residents are doing voluntary evacuations ahead of the implosion, which is scheduled for Monday morning.   Others said they will stay to witness history from their windows.  WSB-TV is partnering with the Georgia World Congress Center Authority for a LIVE broadcast of the Georgia Dome demolition. WATCH Channel 2 Action News This Morning starting at 4:30 a.m. for LIVE Team 2 Coverage. Some people had notices on their front doors warning them about road closures Monday. Atlanta police said they have an intricate safety plan to keep people far away from the site. There will be no public viewing area for the demolition.  What you need to know about security sweeps, detours and the implosion aftermath, on Channel 2 Action News at 6 p.m. These are on the front doors of Vine City neighbors. Some are leaving ahead of Monday’s @GeorgiaDome implosion. Others are staying put to witness history from their windows. @wsbtv pic.twitter.com/v4AC8954vW — Nicole Carr (@NicoleCarrWSB) November 17, 2017   RELATED STORIES: WSB-TV has partnership to broadcast Georgia Dome implosion LIVE MARTA announces alternate service plan for Georgia Dome implosion Mercedes-Benz Stadium will be protected when the Georgia Dome comes down This is what the Georgia Dome implosion will look like Georgia Dome implosion set for Nov. 20 at 7:30 a.m.
  • A priest who wasn't allowed to preach instead turned his ears and heart to the needy. Now, decades after his death, Solanus Casey is on a path to sainthood, celebrated as an incredibly humble man who brought people to God.Father Solanus, as he was known, will be beatified Saturday at a Mass attended by 65,000 people at a stadium in Detroit where he spent much of his ministry. Pope Francis said he met the requirements to earn the title of 'blessed,' especially after a woman from Panama was instantly cured of a chronic skin disease while she prayed at his tomb in 2012.Father Solanus can be made a saint in the years ahead if a second miracle is attributed to him. He'll be only the second U.S.-born man to be beatified by the Roman Catholic Church, joining the Rev. Stanley Rother, a priest killed in Guatamala's civil war, who was beatified in Oklahoma in September. One U.S.-born woman has been beatified and two others have been declared saints.'It's a great event,' Archbishop Allen Vigneron, who leads the southeastern Michigan church, said of the honor for Father Solanus. 'It's hard to communicate how vivid and real the presence of Father is to our community.'Even 60 years after his death, 'people don't say, 'I'm going to Father's tomb,'' Vigneron told The Associated Press. 'They say, 'I'm going to talk to Father.''Father Solanus, a native of Oak Grove, Wisconsin, joined the Capuchin religious order in Detroit in 1897 and was ordained a priest seven years later. But there were conditions: Because of academic struggles, he was prohibited from giving homilies at Mass and couldn't hear confessions.'He accepted it,' said the Rev. Martin Pable, 86, a fellow Capuchin. 'He believed whatever God wants, that's what he would do.'He served for 20 years in New York City and nearby Yonkers before the Capuchins transferred him back to the St. Bonaventure Monastery in Detroit in 1924. Wearing a traditional brown hooded robe and sandals, Father Solanus worked as a porter or doorkeeper for the next two decades, but his reputation for holiness far exceeded his modest title.The unemployed shared their anxieties with Father Solanus, the parents of wayward kids sought his advice, and the ill and addicted asked him to urge God to heal them. As he listened, he took notes that were later turned into typewritten volumes of his work.Later in life, when Father Solanus was stationed at a seminary in Huntington, Indiana, Detroiters boarded buses for a four-hour ride just to see the man with a wispy white beard. Mail piled up from across the country.'He had a gentle presence. He left people with a wonderful feeling of peace inside their hearts,' Pable said. 'He would say, 'Let's just pray about this and see what God wants to do.' Some people were not healed. He told them to bear their problems with God's help.'Father Solanus, who died in 1957, also co-founded the Capuchin Soup Kitchen, which serves up to 2,000 meals a day to Detroit's poor.The Capuchins built a center that bears his name and explains his life story. The public is invited to pray and leave handwritten pleas atop his tomb. Father Solanus' name is invoked by many people who attend a weekly service for the sick.Shirley Wilson, 78, said she regularly prayed to Father Solanus to help her nephew get a kidney. He got one a few weeks ago.'It was a perfect match,' she said. 'I believe in miracles.'Vigneron hopes Father Solanus will inspire people to show mercy toward others.'We need to care for the poor and give them a high priority,' the archbishop said. 'Father was very loving and understanding to people who came to him with their troubles.'___Follow Ed White at https://twitter.com/edwhiteap
  • The ultra-wealthy, especially those with dynastic businesses — like President Donald Trump and his family — do very well under a major Republican tax bill moving in the Senate, as they do under legislation passed this week by the House.Want to toast the anticipated tax win with champagne or a beer — or maybe you're feeling Shakespearean and prefer to quaff mead from a pewter mug? That would cheer producers of beer, wine, liquor — and mead, the ancient beverage fermented from honey. Tax rates on their sales would be reduced under the Senate bill.On the other hand, people living in high-tax states, who deduct their local property, income and sales taxes from what they owe Uncle Sam, could lose out from the complete or partial repeal of the deductions. And an estimated 13 million Americans could lose health insurance coverage over 10 years under the Senate bill.Some winners and losers:__WINNERS— Wealthy individuals and their heirs win big. The hottest class-warfare debate around the tax overhaul legislation involves the inheritance tax on multimillion-dollar estates. Democrats wave the legislation's targeting of the tax as a red flag in the face of Republicans, as proof that they're out to benefit wealthy donors. The House bill initially doubles the limits — to $11 million for individuals and $22 million for couples — on how much money in the estate can be exempted from the inheritance tax, then repeals it entirely after 2023. The Senate version also doubles the limits but doesn't repeal the tax.Then there's the alternative minimum tax, a levy aimed at ensuring that higher-earning people pay at least some tax. It disappears in both bills.And the House measure cuts tax rates for many of the millions of 'pass-through' businesses big and small — including partnerships and specially organized corporations — whose profits are taxed at the owners' personal income rate. That's potential cha-ching for Trump's far-flung property empire and the holdings of his daughter Ivanka and her husband, Jared Kushner. The Senate bill lets pass-through owners deduct some of the earnings and then pay at their personal income rate on the remainder.— Corporations win all around, with a tax rate slashed from 35 percent to 20 percent in both bills — though they'd have to wait a year for it under the Senate measure. Trump and the administration view it as an untouchable centerpiece of the legislation.— U.S. oil companies with foreign operations would pay reduced taxes under the Senate bill on their income from sales of oil and natural gas abroad.— Beer, wine and liquor producers would reap tax reductions under the Senate measure.— Companies that provide management services like maintenance for aircraft get an updated win. The Senate bill clarifies that under current law, the management companies would be exempt from paying taxes on payments they receive from owners of private jets as well as from commercial airlines. That was a request from Ohio Sens. Rob Portman, a Republican, and Sherrod Brown, a Democrat, whose state is home to NetJets, a big aircraft management company.Portman voted for the overall bill. Brown opposed it.__LOSERS— An estimated 13 million Americans could lose health insurance coverage under the Senate bill, which would repeal the 'Obamacare' requirement that everyone in the U.S. have health insurance. The projection comes from the nonpartisan Congressional Budget Office. Eliminating the fines is expected to mean fewer people would obtain federally subsidized health policies.— People living in high-tax states would be hit by repeal of federal deductions for state and local taxes under the Senate bill, and partial repeal under the House measure. That result of a compromise allows the deduction for up to $10,000 in property taxes.— Many families making less than $30,000 a year would face tax increases starting in 2021 under the Senate bill, according to Congress' nonpartisan Joint Committee on Taxation. By 2027, families earning less than $75,000 would see their tax bills rise while those making more would enjoy reductions, the analysts find. The individual income-tax reductions in the Senate bill would end in 2026.