Listen Live:

UK’s Sky News coverage of London terror attack

ON AIR NOW

LISTEN NOW

Weather

cloudy-day Created with Sketch.
51°
Broken Clouds
H 60° L 47°
  • cloudy-day Created with Sketch.
    51°
    Current Conditions
    Broken Clouds. H 60° L 47°
  • cloudy-day Created with Sketch.
    61°
    Today
    Partly Cloudy. H 70° L 54°
  • cloudy-day Created with Sketch.
    71°
    Tomorrow
    Partly Cloudy. H 70° L 54°
LISTEN
PAUSE
ERROR

Wsb news on-demand

00:00 | 00:00

LISTEN
PAUSE
ERROR

Wsb traffic on-demand

00:00 | 00:00

LISTEN
PAUSE
ERROR

Wsb weather on-demand

00:00 | 00:00

Business
Tax plan stirs clash of titans
Close

Tax plan stirs clash of titans

Tax plan stirs clash of titans
Photo Credit: Chris Stewart
Chris Hanes, sales manager at P&R Communications Service, is seen with a new digital two-way radio used by the public safety sector. P&R representatives are in favor of the Marketplace Fairness Act that would require retailers to collect sales tax on online sales. CHRIS STEWART / STAFF

Tax plan stirs clash of titans

An online sales-tax proposal has triggered a divisive debate among business owners and attracted a strange-bedfellows mix of supporters that includes the Dayton Area Chamber of Commerce and Democratic U.S. Sen. Sherrod Brown.

The “Marketplace Fairness Act,” which will be voted on by the U.S. Senate as early as Monday, would require Internet retailers with more than $1 million in out-of-state sales to collect sales tax on purchases made online.

Proponents say the legislation will eliminate an unfair advantage that online retailers currently enjoy over bricks and mortar shops, thereby leveling the playing field and saving Ohio-based jobs.

Opponents say it would stifle competition and add an unfair burden on Internet retailers by forcing them to become revenue collectors for 9,600 sales-tax jurisdictions in America — each with its own set of rules and filing requirements. And they say legislators who support the legislation are voting for a tax increase.

A true battle of titans has emerged with retailers’ groups, small-business owners, Walmart and Amazon.com squaring off against the likes of eBay, a collection of small businesses called Web-Enabled Retailers Helping Expand Retail Employment and anti-tax groups such as Americans for Prosperity and Americans for Tax Reform.

The stakes are high. The National Council of State Legislatures estimates that in 2012 alone, states lost out on a collective $23 billion because they were not able to collect sales tax revenue on remote sales. Ohio’s portion of that bounty exceeded $628 million. And a 2011 study by the University of Cincinnati found that the loss of taxes from Internet sales cost the state of Ohio about 11,000 direct jobs that year.

Depending on who you listen to, the law is either a long-overdue measure to equalize competition to better reflect the buying habits of the modern consumer, or an attempt to stifle commerce and penalize states like Oregon and New Hampshire that do not currently have a sales tax.

Current law

For now, states can require stores to collect sales taxes only if the store is physically located in that state. The Marketplace Fairness Act would give states the additional authority to collect sales taxes on Internet purchases, although businesses with less than $1 million a year in sales (and thus the small eBay seller) would be exempt.

Sales taxes would go to the state where the shopper lives, meaning a shopper in Ohio who buys from an online retailer in Michigan would see their sales tax go to Ohio.

Many states — including Ohio — have laws requiring shoppers to pay sales taxes regardless of whether they bought the item in a store or online. But that requirement has never really been enforced and Gordon Gough, executive vice president and CFO for the Ohio Council of Retail Merchants, said fewer than 1 percent of the population actually abides by that rule.

“It would be impossible (to know),” he said. “Unless you go through everyone’s credit card statements.”

In three procedural votes leading up to this week’s scheduled up-or-down vote, the legislation has received support from about two-thirds of the members of the U.S. Senate, including both Ohio senators. But Caitlin Dunn, a spokesman for Sen. Rob Portman, said the Ohio Republican is still examining the bill’s impact and has not decided how he will vote on the final version. Portman, she said, “will not support policies that excessively burden businesses and consumers.”

Most experts expect the bill will easily pass the Senate, but its fate in the GOP-led U.S. House of Representatives is less certain. If it does pass there, however, it will likely become law since President Barack Obama has already indicated his support.

In Ohio, House Republicans recently added language to the state budget bill that positions Ohio to collect the tax should Congress pass the Marketplace Fairness Act.

Business vs. Business

The issue has meant business owners who usually see eye to eye on political and economic matters are on opposite sides of the fence.

Matt Howitt — vice president of Next Lift Inc., a Moraine company that sells, services and rents forklifts and other material-handling equipment — strongly opposes the legislation because he says it will burden small companies such as his. Howitt said he does about 90 percent of his business on the Internet.

“The economy is still struggling as it is,” Howitt said. “Now they’re trying to turn small businesses into revenue enforcers and tax collectors.”

Next Lift ships products “all over the country every day” that have been purchased online, Howitt said. And the company’s employees don’t have the time or resources to fill out tax forms for the 9,600 tax jurisdictions in the U.S. “That doesn’t help create jobs,” Howitt said. “It stops jobs.”

But Nikki Hanes, general manager of P & R Communications Service in downtown Dayton, supports the tax plan because she says the current system penalizes companies like hers. P & R Communications sells two-way radio and wireless broadband equipment and, like other bricks-and-mortar retail stores, charges sales tax on its commercial sales. That gives Hanes’ online competitors an immediate 6 to 7 percent advantage in pricing, she said.

“We have enough competition on margins alone,” Hanes said. “I would like to see an even playing field for all of us when it comes to sales taxes.”

John Marshall, vice president of retail operations for Grismer Tire Company, said he has frequently encountered customers who come into one of Grismer’s 24 stores in the Dayton, Springfield, Fairfield and Columbus areas, price the tires his company sells, then head out to buy the same product online. They do this, he said, to avoid paying sales tax.

“It’s put us at a decided competitive disadvantage,” said Marshall, “People are telling us flat-out that they’re going to end up buying (a product) and having it shipped in because they could save on sales tax.”

In the end, the fate of the bill will likely depend on which business group best sells their narrative of fairness.

Norman Singleton of the Campaign for Liberty, which opposes the Senate bill, said the measure would cause online retailers to raise prices twice — once to add the taxes, and again for compliance costs. While a provision in the bill would allow businesses to receive free software to handle different state tax rates, Singleton questions whether the cost of providing such software and the hassle of using it might be an onerous burden.

“It’s certainly going to raise taxes, raise costs and raise the cost of doing business online,” Singleton said.

Read More
VIEW COMMENTS

There are no comments yet. Be the first to post your thoughts. or Register.

News

  • An off-duty Fulton County police officer shot a man after a chase in Atlanta Wednesday morning, the GBI says. The officer, whose name has not been released, was in his personal vehicle about 11 a.m., when he responded to a theft at a T-Mobile store on Mount Zion Parkway in Morrow, GBI spokesman Rich Bahan said.  The officer followed the suspect’s car into the city limits of Atlanta while reporting the incident to 911, Bahan said. At some point near Alyson Court, the two cars collided and when the driver got out of his car the off-duty officer shot him with his service weapon, Bahan said.   MORE:  Sheriff: Man out on bond for murder arrested after fighting victim’s family Ex-NFL player jailed after allegedly attacking woman in front of kids Police: Men brought ‘bag of bullets’ to shootout with alleged gang members Witness Jay Mitchell told Channel 2 Action News he thinks the man was shot in the stomach area after the police officer chased him and tried to pull him over. The suspect kept driving even after he was shot, Bahan said, and Atlanta police stopped him in the 1700 block of Lakewood Avenue. Whether the off-duty Fulton County officer stayed on the scene was not released, but his car was found parked at a store on Cleveland Avenue, Channel 2 reported. The man who was shot was taken to Grady Memorial Hospital, Bahan said. The shooting is the fourth in less than a week involving a Georgia officer. A Georgia State Patrol trooper fatally shot a man after a chase early Saturday in Polk County. Jason Dennis Watkins, 36, was taken to Polk County Hospital, where he was pronounced dead. RELATED: GSP trooper fatally shoots man after chase Willie Ivy III, 29, of Atlanta, died after a Fulton County police officer and an armed security guard shot him early Saturday in College Park, the GBI said.  RELATED: Man dead in police-involved shooting incident in College Park A Pickens County sheriff’s sergeant on Tuesday shot and critically injured Gary Lee Castle after he “moved aggressively” toward the official “with a large metal pipe in his hand,” the sheriff’s office said. RELATED: Sergeant shoots, critically injures man, Pickens County sheriff says In January and February, the GBI conducted 17 officer-involved shooting investigations, agency spokeswoman Nelly Miles said. RELATED: OVER THE LINE: Police shootings in Georgia The GBI investigated 78 police shootings in the state last year. In other news:
  • A middle school bus driver in the Valdosta area is accused of driving under the influence of alcohol while students were on her bus, according to the Lowndes County sheriff. Amanda Mullinax, 41, registered more than twice the legal limit, Lowndes County Sheriff Ashley Paulk said. A school resource officer at Hahira Middle School smelled alcohol on Mullinax, and a student said she had been drinking, the Macon Telegraph reported. The night before, deputies were called to a domestic dispute at Mullinax’s home and found she had been drinking heavily, Paulk said. RELATED: School bus driver charged in accident that injured child She could face multiple counts of child endangerment since there were about 44 students on the bus, the newspaper reported. Read more of the story here. In other news:
  • U.S. Supreme Court nominee Neil Gorsuch vowed to uphold the law if confirmed to the nation’s highest court, not tipping his hand as he sidestepped controversial political subjects, as Gorsuch directly pushed back against President Donald Trump’s criticism of federal judges. “When anyone criticizes the honesty or integrity, the motives of a federal judge, I find that disheartening; I find that demoralizing,” Gorsuch said in response to questions from Sen. Richard Blumenthal (D-CT). “Anyone including the President of the United States?” Blumenthal pressed. “Anyone is anyone,” Gorsuch replied. In a day of testimony that stretched for almost twelve hours, Gorsuch parried most questions from Democrats, who tried in vain to get him to reveal his views on issues like abortion, and items that might come before the Supreme Court, like President Trump’s travel ban. Gorsuch repeatedly refused to take the bait. “I can’t get involved in politics, and I think it would be very imprudent of judges to start commenting on political disputes,” Gorsuch said. Under questioning from Sen. Lindsey Graham (R-SC), Gorsuch was asked what he had discussed with President Trump on the issue of abortion. “In that interview did he ever ask you to overrule Roe v Wade?” Graham asked. “No, Senator,” Gorsuch replied, adding that if the President had asked that question, “I would have walked out the door.” Gorsuch was pressed about the President in a number of different ways, telling Sen. Patrick Leahy (D-VT) that, “nobody is above the law in this country, and that includes the President of the United States.” With Republicans strongly in support of Gorsuch, there was already maneuvering behind the scenes over the expected floor fight in the Senate, as Democrats have made clear they think the GOP should be forced to get 60 votes for his nomination. That has prompted GOP leaders to criticize the threat of a filibuster. “If there aren’t 60 votes for a nominee like Neil Gorsuch it’s appropriate to ask the question is there any nominee any Republican president could make that Democrats would approve,” said Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell. Gorsuch’s lengthy day of testimony ended on a light note, as Sen. John Kennedy (R-LA) suggested to Gorsuch that he have a cocktail before bed. “Just don’t drink vodka,” Kennedy said to chuckles from the audience. Kennedy then drew even more laughter by adding in one more surprise. “You never been to Russia, have you?” “I’ve never been to Russia,” a smiling Gorsuch said.
  • The conservative party of Prime Minister Mark Rutte and three other parties have agreed to begin talks about forming the next ruling coalition, but are warning that there are major differences to bridge before a deal can be struck. The parties, Rutte's VVD, the Christian Democrats, the social democratic D66 and left-wing Green Left, met Thursday for exploratory talks with their leaders saying they are prepared to enter more formal discussions. Rutte says he is 'prepared to talk more but ... the political differences between these parties are significant.' Despite losing seats, the VVD topped elections last week for the 150-seat lower house of Parliament and is in line to lead the next coalition. The Christian Democrats, D66 and Green Left all made gains in the election.